How to NOT use while() loops in verilog (for synthesis)?

loops verilog synthesis
chester.boo picture chester.boo · Mar 2, 2010 · Viewed 15k times · Source

I've gotten in the habit of developing a lot testbenches and use for() and while() loops for testing purpose. Thats fine. The problem is that I've taken this habit over to coding for circuits which should be synthesizable. XST and others refuse to synthesize code (without additional modification to synthesis parameters) such as:

while (num < test_number) 
     begin 
     . 
     . 
     . 
     num = num+1; 
     end

This is bad coding style because to the synthesizer test_num is an int with value 2^32! or it sees it as unbounded parameter. Either way, its a bad coding habit. But I'm so used to doing this in C and testbenches. What would be the equivalent synthesizable of code of the above code segment?

Thanks!

Answer

Steve K picture Steve K · Mar 10, 2010

Synthesis tools vary but generally a loop can be synthesized so long as the number of iterations is known a to the synthesis tool. So, 

for ( i = 0; i < 10; i = i + 1 )

is OK because the tool knows there are 10 loop iterations. But

reg [10:0] r;
for ( i = 0; i < r; i = i + 1 )

is not OK because r is a variable r's value is unknown at synthesis time.

Think of loops in RTL code as creating a known fixed number of copies of a piece of logic.

Related questions

How to break always block in Verilog?

I am trying to simulate a simple MIPS processor using behavior code in Verilog. I have finished writing the code but I reach to a final step where I want to break the always block after done with executing the …

Read More
For-each over an array in JavaScript

How can I loop through all the entries in an array using JavaScript? I thought it was something like this: forEach(instance in theArray) Where theArray is my array, but this seems to be incorrect.

Read More
Loop through an array in JavaScript

In Java you can use a for loop to traverse objects in an array as follows: String[] myStringArray = {"Hello", "World"}; for (String s : myStringArray) { // Do something } Can you do the same in JavaScript?

Read More