RhinoMock vs. TypeMock vs. NUnit's Mocking?

unit-testing nunit mocking rhino-mocks typemock
Dan Appleyard picture Dan Appleyard · Sep 4, 2009 · Viewed 13.9k times · Source

I am just starting to do Test Driven Development, and I am wondering the major differences between RhinoMock, TypeMock, and NUnit's built-in mocking?

Any information would be greatly appreciated!

Answer

Kirschstein picture Kirschstein · Sep 4, 2009

TypeMock is a commercial product (meaning you'll have to pay for it) but will allow you to mock concrete objects - unlike RhinoMocks/NUnit/MoQ which can only mock an interface/abstract class. How it achieves this is borderline black magic, but it does some very clever things with the CLR.

This can be particularly useful when you use libraries in your project that don't use many interfaces. So you could, for example, use TypeMock to mock out a LINQtoSQL datacontext, or Sharepoint objects. However, if you are using TypeMock this is no excuse for bad design in your application.

As far as I'm aware, aside from minor syntax differences, most of the mocking frameworks have moved away from the old record/playback model. Commonly, you set up your mocks by writing expectations using a Fluent Interface.

Personally, I have only used MoQ and I <3 it.

Related questions

Moq: Setup a mocked method to fail on the first call, succeed on the second

What's the most succinct way to use Moq to mock a method that will throw an exception the first time it is called, then succeed the second time it is called?

Read More
How can we run a test method with multiple parameters in MSTest?

NUnit has a feature called Values, like below: [Test] public void MyTest( [Values(1,2,3)] int x, [Values("A","B")] string s) { // ... } This means that the test method will run six times: MyTest(1, "A") MyTest(1, "B") MyTest(2, "A") MyTest(2, "B") MyTest(3, "A") …

Read More
NUnit vs. MbUnit vs. MSTest vs. xUnit.net

There are quite a lot of unittesting frameworks out there for .NET. I found this little feature comparison: http://xunit.github.io/docs/comparisons.html Now I am to choose the best one for us. But how? Does it matter? …

Read More