R: apt-get install r-cran-foo vs. install.packages("foo")

Question

When installing R packages (say mcmcpack in this example) under Ubuntu I have the choice between the following two methods of installation:

# Let the distribution's packaging system take care of installation/upgrades
apt-get install r-cran-mcmcpack

# Let R take care of installation/upgrades
install.packages("mcmcpack")

Questions:

• Is any of the two ways of installing R packages considered "best practice"?
• Assume that I first install.packages("mcmcpack") and later on apt-get install r-cran-mcmcpack - should I expect trouble?
• Assume that I first apt-get install r-cran-mcmcpack and later on install.packages("mcmcpack") - should I expect trouble?

Answer 1

It's not as easy as it seems.

• apt-get update is good if and when

  • packages exist -- but there are only around 150 or so r-cran-* packages out of a pool of 2100+ packages on CRAN, so rather sparse coverage

  • packages are maintained, bug free and current

  • you are happy enough with the bi-annual releases by Ubuntu

• install.packages() and later update.packages() is good if and when

  • you know what it takes to have built-time dependencies (besides r-base-dev) installed

  • you don't mind running update.packages() by hand as well as the apt-get updates.

On my Ubuntu machine at work, I go with the second solution. But because the first one is better if you have enough coverage, we have built cran2deb which provides 2050+ binary deb packages for amd64 and i386 --- but only for Debian testing. That is what I use at home.

As for last question of whether you 'should you expect trouble': No, because R_LIBS_SITE is set in /etc/R/Renvironment to be

# edd Apr 2003  Allow local install in /usr/local, also add a directory for
#               Debian packaged CRAN packages, and finally the default dir 
# edd Jul 2007  Now use R_LIBS_SITE, not R_LIBS
R_LIBS_SITE=${R_LIBS_SITE-'/usr/local/lib/R/site-library:\
/usr/lib/R/site-library:/usr/lib/R/library'}

which means that your packages go into /usr/local/lib/R/site-library whereas those managed by apt go into /usr/lib/R/site-library and (in the case of base packages) /usr/lib/R/library.

Hope that clarifies matters. The r-sig-debian mailing list is a more informed place for questions like this.