What property should I use for a Dispatch Queue after ARC?

Z S picture Z S · Jan 18, 2012 · Viewed 21.4k times · Source

I maintain a dispatch queue as a property with my view controller. I create this queue once in my view controller's init method, and reuse a few times for some background tasks. Before ARC, I was doing this:

@property (nonatomic, assign) dispatch_queue_t filterMainQueue;

And in init:

if (filterMainQueue == nil) {
     filterMainQueue = dispatch_queue_create("com.myQueue.CJFilterMainQueue", NULL);
}

But after ARC, I'm not sure if this should still be "assign", or should it be "strong" or "weak". The ARC convertor script didn't change anything but I'm not sure if a subtle bug is coming from the fact that this queue might be deallocated while it's being used?

What would be the difference between the 3 types of properties, and what will work the best for a dispatch queue, when using ARC?

Answer

Lily Ballard picture Lily Ballard · Jan 18, 2012

Updated answer:

In current OS X and iOS, Dispatch objects are now treated as Obj-C objects by ARC. They will be memory-managed the same way that Obj-C objects will, and you should use strong for your property.

This is controlled by the OS_OBJECT_USE_OBJC macro, defined in <os/object.h>. It's set to 1 by default when your deployment target is OS X 10.8 or higher, or iOS 6.0 or higher. If you're deploying to an older OS, then this is left at 0 and you should see my original answer below.


Original answer:

Dispatch objects (including queues) are not Obj-C objects, so the only possible choice is assign. The compiler will throw an error if you try to use strong or weak. ARC has no impact on GCD.