Why JSON allows only string to be a key?

javascript json ecma262
pipipi picture pipipi · Feb 16, 2012 · Viewed 19.5k times · Source

Why does JSON only allow a string to be a key of a pair? Why not other types such as null, number, bool, object, array? Considering JSON is tightly related with JavaScript, could I conclude the reason from JavaScript specification (ECMA-262)? I'm totally a newbie to JavaScript, could you help me to point it out.

Answer

nnnnnn picture nnnnnn · Feb 16, 2012

The JSON format is deliberately based on a subset of JavaScript object literal syntax and array literal syntax, and JavaScript objects can only have strings as keys - thus JSON keys are strings too. (OK, you can sort of use numbers as JavaScript object keys, but really they get converted to strings.)

Note that the point of JSON is that it is a string representation of data to allow easy exchange between programs written in different languages running on different machines in different environments. If you wanted to use an object as a key then that object would in turn have to be somehow represented as a string for transmission, but then the receiving language would need to be able to use objects as keys and that would mean you'd need a limited subset of JSON for those languages which would just be a mess.

"Considering JSON is a part of JavaScript"

No, it isn't. Newer browsers provide methods for creating and parsing JSON, but they're not part of the language as such except that JSON is a string format and JavaScript can do strings. JSON is always a string representation - it has to be parsed to create an object for use within JavaScript (or other languages) and once that happens JavaScript (or the other languages) treat the resulting object the same as any other object.

(Note also that a particular bit of JSON doesn't necessarily have any keys at all: it could just be an array, like '["one","two","three"]'.)

Related questions

JSON left out Infinity and NaN; JSON status in ECMAScript?

Any idea why JSON left out NaN and +/- Infinity? It puts Javascript in the strange situation where objects that would otherwise be serializable, are not, if they contain NaN or +/- infinity values. Looks like this has been cast …

Read More
Parse JSON in JavaScript?

I want to parse a JSON string in JavaScript. The response is something like var response = '{"result":true,"count":1}'; How can I get the values result and count from this?

Read More
Convert JS object to JSON string

If I defined an object in JS with: var j={"name":"binchen"}; How can I convert the object to JSON? The output string should be: '{"name":"binchen"}'

Read More