Find model in Backbone.js collection by cid rather than id

javascript backbone.js backbone.js-collections
prototype picture prototype · Jan 25, 2013 · Viewed 13.1k times · Source

Can I use Collection.get(id) to find a model within a Backbone.js collection by cid, for a model not yet saved to the server?

From the documentation, it seems like .get should find a model by either its id or cid. However, collection.get(cid) doesn't find the model, whereas this does, collection.find(function(model) {return model.cid===cid; }). Presumably I'm overlooking something basic.

jsFiddle for example below

var Element = Backbone.Model.extend({});
var Elements = Backbone.Collection.extend({ model:  Element });

var elements = new Elements(), el, cids = [];

for (var i=0; i<4; i++) {
    el = new Element({name: "element"+i})
    elements.add(el);
    cids.push(el.cid);
}

console.log(cids);
el1 = elements.get(cids[0]);     
console.log(el1);  // undefined


el1a = elements.find(function(model) { return model.cid === cids[0]; });
console.log(el1a);  // success

Backbone.js - id vs idAttribute vs cid

Answer

Bryan A picture Bryan A · Jan 25, 2013

In backbone 0.9.9 (see changelog), they removed the .getByCid() method and folded that functionality directly into .get() -- if you're using below 0.9.9, you can use the .getByCid() method; I think they've since removed it from the docs to reflect the most current state of the library.

Edit:

See @Ferdinand Prantl's comment below for more detail, but passing the cid as the property of an object literal will accomplish what you're looking for here: .get({ cid: "xxx" }). My apologies for any confusion.

Related questions

How to find a model from a collection according to some attribute other than the ID?

I have a model with several object: //Model Friend = Backbone.Model.extend({ //Create a model to hold friend attribute name: null, }); //objects var f1 = new Friend({ name: "Lee" }); var f2 = new Friend({ name: "David"}); var f3 = new Friend({ name: "Lynn"}); …

Read More
Backbone.js collection options

I have written a model/view/collection using Backbone.js. My collection uses the fetch method to load the models from a remote server. The url required for this collection needs an id like: messages/{id}. But I have found …

Read More
Collection add event listener in Backbone

I am trying to update my view whenever I add a new model to my collection. My first question is do I automatically add a model to my collection when I save that model, like: PostsApp.Views.Form = Backbone.View.…

Read More