Why is there no GIL in the Java Virtual Machine? Why does Python need one so bad?

java python multithreading jvm gil
AgentLiquid picture AgentLiquid · Jun 14, 2009 · Viewed 17.7k times · Source

I'm hoping someone can provide some insight as to what's fundamentally different about the Java Virtual Machine that allows it to implement threads nicely without the need for a Global Interpreter Lock (GIL), while Python necessitates such an evil.

Answer

Alex Martelli picture Alex Martelli · Jun 14, 2009

Python (the language) doesn't need a GIL (which is why it can perfectly be implemented on JVM [Jython] and .NET [IronPython], and those implementations multithread freely). CPython (the popular implementation) has always used a GIL for ease of coding (esp. the coding of the garbage collection mechanisms) and of integration of non-thread-safe C-coded libraries (there used to be a ton of those around;-).

The Unladen Swallow project, among other ambitious goals, does plan a GIL-free virtual machine for Python -- to quote that site, "In addition, we intend to remove the GIL and fix the state of multithreading in Python. We believe this is possible through the implementation of a more sophisticated GC system, something like IBM's Recycler (Bacon et al, 2001)."

Related questions

WhatsApp API (java/python)

I am looking for WhatsApp API, preferably a Python or Java library. I've tried Yowsup, but could not get my number registered; I am based in India and I am not sure if that has got anything to do with …

Read More
Compiled vs. Interpreted Languages

I'm trying to get a better understanding of the difference. I've found a lot of explanations online, but they tend towards the abstract differences rather than the practical implications. Most of my programming experiences has been with CPython (dynamic, interpreted), …

Read More
Calling Python in Java?

I am wondering if it is possible to call python functions from java code using jython, or is it only for calling java code from python?

Read More