Java WatchService not generating events while watching mapped drives

java file nio mapped-drive watchservice
Ramcis picture Ramcis · Dec 12, 2011 · Viewed 21.5k times · Source

I implemented a file watcher but I noticed that java nio file watcher doesn't generate events for files being copied on mapped drives. For instance, I've run the file watcher on Unix to watch a local directory (/sharedfolder) which is mapped on windows (H:\), and then I've put a file in this directory (H:\) but the file watcher hasn't generated any event. Now if I run the file watcher on windows to watcher the mapped drive (H:\) which refers to a unix path (/sharedfolder) and from unix I put a file in this folder, the file watcher identifies the change and generates an event. It looks like a bug, or may be I'm missing some thing, any thoughts?

Answer

Tim Van Laer picture Tim Van Laer · Sep 19, 2012

I have the same issue trying to watch a mounted windows share via CIFS. It seems not possible to get filesystem events for CIFS mounts.

The linux implementation of the Java 7 NIO FileWatcher uses inotify. Inotify is a linux kernel subsystem to notice filesystem changes which works perfect for local directories, but apparently not for CIFS mounts.

At Oracle, it doesn't seem to be high priority to fix this bug. (Is it their responsibility? More of an OS issue...)

JNotify also uses inotify on linux systems, so this is no option either.

So mapped drives monitoring unfortunately seems to be limited to pollers:

  • Apache VFS DefaultFileMonitor to poll directories (mounted share)
  • File Poller based on the standard Java API.
  • Custom File Poller with jCIFS (so the share doesn't need to be mounted on the host)

I'll probably try the Apache VFS Monitor, because it detects file creation, updates and deletes out of the box. It requires to mount the share, but that gives the OS the responsibility of CIFS connections and not my application.

Related questions

Recursively list files in Java

How do I recursively list all files under a directory in Java? Does the framework provide any utility? I saw a lot of hacky implementations. But none from the framework or nio

Read More
Java NIO FileChannel versus FileOutputstream performance / usefulness

I am trying to figure out if there is any difference in performance (or advantages) when we use nio FileChannel versus normal FileInputStream/FileOuputStream to read and write files to filesystem. I observed that on my machine both perform at …

Read More
Recursively list all files within a directory using nio.file.DirectoryStream;

I want to list all the FILES within the specified directory and subdirectories within that directory. No directories should be listed. My current code is below. It does not work properly as it only lists the files and directories within …

Read More