Java: Rationale of the Cloneable interface

java clone specifications cloneable
Ande Turner picture Ande Turner · Apr 2, 2009 · Viewed 7.6k times · Source

Why wasn't the .clone() method specified in the java.lang.Cloneable interface ?

Answer

Bill the Lizard picture Bill the Lizard · Apr 2, 2009

Basically, it's a broken interface. Ken Arnold and Bill Venners discussed it in Java Design Issues.

Arnold:

If I were to be God at this point, and many people are probably glad I am not, I would say deprecate Cloneable and have a Copyable, because Cloneable has problems. Besides the fact that it's misspelled, Cloneable doesn't contain the clone method. That means you can't test if something is an instance of Cloneable, cast it to Cloneable, and invoke clone. You have to use reflection again, which is awful. That is only one problem, but one I'd certainly solve.

Related questions

How do I copy an object in Java?

Consider the code below: DummyBean dum = new DummyBean(); dum.setDummy("foo"); System.out.println(dum.getDummy()); // prints 'foo' DummyBean dumtwo = dum; System.out.println(dumtwo.getDummy()); // prints 'foo' dum.setDummy("bar"); System.out.println(dumtwo.getDummy()); // prints 'bar' but it …

Read More
How to clone ArrayList and also clone its contents?

How can I clone an ArrayList and also clone its items in Java? For example I have: ArrayList<Dog> dogs = getDogs(); ArrayList<Dog> clonedList = ....something to do with dogs.... And I would expect that objects in …

Read More
How do you make a deep copy of an object?

It's a bit difficult to implement a deep object copy function. What steps you take to ensure the original object and the cloned one share no reference?

Read More