Am I crazy? Switching an established product from HSQLDB to Apache Derby
I have an established software product that uses HSQLDB as its internal settings database. Customer projects are stored in this database. Over the years, HSQLDB has served us reasonably well, but it has some stability/corruption issues that we've had to code circles around, and even then, we can't seem to protect ourselves from them completely.
I'm considering changing internal databases. Doing this would be fairly painful from a development perspective, but corrupted databases (and lost data) are not fun to explain to customers.
So my question is: Does anyone have enough experience to weigh in on the long-term stability of Apache Derby? I found a post via Google complaining that Derby was unstable, but it was from 2006 so I'd entertain the idea that it has been improved in the last 4 years. Or, is there another pure Java embedded (in-process) database that I could use (commercial or open-source). Performance isn't very important to me. Stability is king. Data integrity across power loss, good BLOB support, and hot-backups are all a must.
Please don't suggest something that isn't a SQL-based relational database. I'm trying to retrofit an existing product, not start from scratch, thanks.
Answer
For each database engine there is a certain risk of corruption. I am the main author of the H2 database, and I also got reports about broken databases. Testing can reduce the probability of bugs, but unfortunately it's almost impossible to guarantee some software is 'bug free'.
As for the three Java database HSQLDB, Apache Derby, and H2, I can't really say which one is the most stable. I can only speak about H2. I think for most operations, H2 is now stable. There are many test cases that specially test for databases getting corrupt. This includes automated tests on power loss (using a christmas light timer). With power failure tests I found out stability also depends on the file system: sometimes I got 'CRC error' messages meaning the operating system can't read the file (it was Windows). In that case, there is not much you can do.
For mission critical data, in any case I wouldn't rely on the software being stable. It's very important to create backups regularly, and test them. Some databases have multiple way to create backups. H2 for example has an online backup feature, and a feature to write a SQL script file. An alternative is to use replication or clustering. H2 supports a simple cluster mode, I believe Derby supports replication.