Apache with JBOSS using AJP (mod_jk) giving spikes in thread count

java multithreading apache jboss ajp
Ashish Jain picture Ashish Jain · Dec 4, 2009 · Viewed 14.7k times · Source

We used Apache with JBOSS for hosting our Application, but we found some issues related to thread handling of mod_jk.

Our website comes under low traffic websites and has maximum 200-300 concurrent users during our website's peak activity time. As the traffic grows (not in terms of concurrent users, but in terms of cumulative requests which came to our server), the server stopped serving requests for long, although it didn't crash but could not serve the request till 20 mins. The JBOSS server console showed that 350 thread were busy on both servers although there was enough free memory say, more than 1-1.5 GB (2 servers for JBOSS were used which were 64 bits, 4 GB RAM allocated for JBOSS)

In order to check the problem we were using JBOSS and Apache Web Consoles, and we were seeing that the thread were showing in S state for as long as minutes although our pages take around 4-5 seconds to be served.

We took the thread dump and found that the threads were mostly in WAITING state which means that they were waiting indefinitely. These threads were not of our Application Classes but of AJP 8009 port.

Could somebody help me in this, as somebody else might also got this issue and solved it somehow. In case any more information is required then let me know.

Also is mod_proxy better than using mod_jk, or there are some other problems with mod_proxy which can be fatal for me if I switch to mod__proxy?

The versions I used are as follows:

Apache 2.0.52
JBOSS: 4.2.2
MOD_JK: 1.2.20
JDK: 1.6
Operating System: RHEL 4

Thanks for the help.

Guys!!!! We finally found the workaround with the configuration mentioned above. It is use of APR and is mentioned here: http://community.jboss.org/thread/153737. Its issue as correctly mentioned by many people in answers below i.e. connector issue. Earlier we made temporary workaround by configuring hibernate and increasing response time. The full fix is APR.

Answer

Naganalf picture Naganalf · Dec 4, 2009

We are experiencing similar issues. We are still working on solutions, but it looks like alot of answers can be found here:

http://www.jboss.org/community/wiki/OptimalModjk12Configuration

Good luck!

Related questions

Difference between wait() and sleep()

What is the difference between a wait() and sleep() in Threads? Is my understanding that a wait()-ing Thread is still in running mode and uses CPU cycles but a sleep()-ing does not consume any CPU cycles correct? Why …

Read More
"implements Runnable" vs "extends Thread" in Java

From what time I've spent with threads in Java, I've found these two ways to write threads: With implements Runnable: public class MyRunnable implements Runnable { public void run() { //Code } } //Started with a "new Thread(new MyRunnable()).start()" call Or, with …

Read More
How to properly stop the Thread in Java?

I need a solution to properly stop the thread in Java. I have IndexProcessorclass which implements the Runnable interface: public class IndexProcessor implements Runnable { private static final Logger LOGGER = LoggerFactory.getLogger(IndexProcessor.class); @Override public void run() { boolean run = true; …

Read More