the significance of java RMI please?

java computer-science rmi software-design anti-patterns
Fermat's Little Student picture Fermat's Little Student · Jan 14, 2013 · Viewed 8.9k times · Source

Why do people use RMI, or when should I use RMI? I read those tutorials about RMI on oracle's website.But it doesn't provides enough practical examples.

To my understanding, a software should have its modules as "unrelated and separated" as possible. RMI somehow seems to be an example of high coupling to me. Why is this not a bad coding practice? I thought the client should only fire instructions,whereas all the actually manipulations of the object were done by the server.

(I am currently working towards a computer science bachelor degree and very inexperienced, so please correct me if I understand those concepts wrong.)

Thanks in advance!

Answer

Alex Recarey picture Alex Recarey · Jan 14, 2013

You really should not be using RMI for any application you build today, basically for the reasons you just laid out.

In some cases (diving into legacy or "enterprise" applications) you just have no choice.

However, if you are starting a new project, other options are:

REST + JSON over HTTP

The de-facto standard for communicating to remote services. The biggest advantage it has it that it is lightweight and easy to grasp the concept.

In theory it should require more work than RMI because you have to manually craft the available URL's, accepted verbs in each URL etc. In practice, I would say that RMI's boilerplate does not really help anybody.

Sticking with java, Jersey is a brilliant library to write your own RESTful web services.

If you want a batteries included solution for RESTful web services with java, Dropwizard by the nice guys at Yammer gives you a full server and framework ready to just plug in your business logic, and provides logging, database connectivity, serialization, request routing, and even metrics gathering out of the box.

SOAP

The previous standard for communicating to remote services. Unless you have a reason to use it, I would stick to REST.

Thrift

Thrift will create a client and a server stub, basically doing much of the work. The communication is in an efficient binary protocol. It's gaining popularity in the Java world as it is used by many open source projects in the "Big Data" field. Examples, Cassandra, HBase (switching to Avro). Scrooge is a twitter project to create idiomatic thrift stubs for scala.

Akka actors

Akka is framework that implements the Actor model for Scala and Java. Includes provisions for inter-service communication, and takes care of many of the details under the hood. I

Depending on your needs, some will be more suitable than others.

Related questions

What do we mean by Byte array?

Could someone please explain, I do not exactly get the concept. What is a Byte Array? Where and when we use it in applications/programs? what are the advantages and disadvantages of using a byte array?

Read More
How does semaphore work?

Can the semaphore be lower than 0? I mean, say I have a semaphore with N=3 and I call "down" 4 times, then N will remain 0 but one process will be blocked? And same the other way, if in the beginning I …

Read More
How do I convert a String to an int in Java?

How can I convert a String to an int in Java? My String contains only numbers, and I want to return the number it represents. For example, given the string "1234" the result should be the number 1234.

Read More