J2ME VS Android VS iPhone VS Symbian VS Windows CE

iphone android java-me windows-ce symbian
Sadi picture Sadi · Sep 12, 2009 · Viewed 36.6k times · Source

I have very little idea about mobile platforms, though I am interested to program for them.

Would you please compare J2ME VS Android VS iPhone VS Symbian VS Windows CE.

I would like to know:

  • which one is better
  • which one should I choose and why
  • if there is any VM technology to test the programs
  • is there any IDE, debugging facilities?

Personally, I would like to code for open source, but any suggestions are welcome. I have preliminary knowledge on Java. I would also like to know, if there is anything else that you can recommend.

Answer

Jeremy Logan picture Jeremy Logan · Sep 12, 2009

There's several of these questions floating around on SO already... the most popular seems to be this one: what mobile platform should I start learning?

Quicky from the accepted answer over there (I edited a bit):

I think 3-4 platform have a future. But depends what platform do you like and how you like freedom in distribute your applications :)

  1. Windows Mobile
    • C++ or .NET
    • free distribution, just like normal applications or through market
    • You need a Windows PC to develop
    • proprietary
  2. Android
    • Java
    • Open Source
    • through Android Market ($25 one-time fees) or like normal applications
    • The platform is completely open source
  3. iPhone
    • Objective-C or Java (Developing iPhone Applications using Java)
    • through iPhone Market ($99/year fees)
    • You need Mac (Mac OS) for development
    • proprietary
  4. Java
    • J2ME or JavaFX
    • largely open source

My personal thoughts are: Symbian's dead; Windows Mobile will die, but take a long time; Android will become the standard in the next few years; iPhone will remain trendy in coming years, but NOT take be the biggest player; Pre/WebOS will maintain a niche market, but not be wildly sucessfull, Blackberry will decline, but still be around forever. I'd probably put my time/money into Android or iPhone at this point.

Related questions

Barcode reading using picture taken using mobile phone camera

How do we do programmatic reading of a barcode that is captured using a mobile phone camera? For example, how do that using iPhone or Android or Java ME? Do we need separate hardware to read bar code or can …

Read More
Capturing mobile phone traffic on Wireshark

How can I capture mobile phone traffic on Wireshark?

Read More
Detect a finger swipe through JavaScript on the iPhone and Android

How can you detect that a user swiped his finger in some direction over a web page with JavaScript? I was wondering if there was one solution that would work for websites on both the iPhone and an Android phone.

Read More