Can't Mod Zero?

c++ modulo divide-by-zero
Dasaru picture Dasaru · Sep 10, 2011 · Viewed 57.5k times · Source

Why is X % 0 an invalid expression?

I always thought X % 0 should equal X. Since you can't divide by zero, shouldn't the answer naturally be the remainder, X (everything left over)?

Answer

Nawaz picture Nawaz · Sep 10, 2011

The C++ Standard(2003) says in §5.6/4,

[...] If the second operand of / or % is zero the behavior is undefined; [...]

That is, following expressions invoke undefined-behavior(UB):

X / 0; //UB
X % 0; //UB

Note also that -5 % 2 is NOT equal to -(5 % 2) (as Petar seems to suggest in his comment to his answer). It's implementation-defined. The spec says (§5.6/4),

[...] If both operands are nonnegative then the remainder is nonnegative; if not, the sign of the remainder is implementation-defined.

Related questions

Why is 0 mod 0 an error?

If I type: int main() { return 0 % 0; } I get back an error: error C2124: divide or mod by zero What is the reason behind this? Isn't the answer zero?

Read More
How to code a modulo (%) operator in C/C++/Obj-C that handles negative numbers

One of my pet hates of C-derived languages (as a mathematician) is that (-1) % 8 // comes out as -1, and not 7 fmodf(-1,8) // fails similarly What's the best solution? C++ allows the possibility of templates and operator overloading, but both of …

Read More
Can't use modulus on doubles?

I have a program in C++ (compiled using g++). I'm trying to apply two doubles as operands to the modulus function, but I get the following error: error: invalid operands of types 'double' and 'double' to binary 'operator%' Here's …

Read More