C# - Get number of references to object

c# reflection resources reference resourcemanager
Spoonman picture Spoonman · Nov 6, 2009 · Viewed 24.1k times · Source

I'm trying to write a simple Resource Manager for the little hobby game I'm writing. One of the tasks that this resource manager needs to do is unloading unused resources. I can think of doing this in two ways:

  • When an object no longer requires a reference to the resource, it must call a method of the Resource Manager to signify it is no longer using it; or

  • When an object no longer requires a reference to the resource, it simply sets it to null. Then when the Resource Manager is asked to unload unused resources, it gets the reference count (via reflection?) of each resource. If the reference count is one (the Resource Manager will have a reference to the resource), unload the resource.

Is there any way to acheive the second solution in C#? Thanks.

Answer

Eric Lippert picture Eric Lippert · Nov 6, 2009

Couple things. First off, objects are not reference counted; reference counting schemes have the circular reference problem, whereby two objects refer to each other but are otherwise inaccessible, and thereby leak. .NET uses a mark-and-sweep approach which does not use ref counts.

Second, though the suggestion to use a weak reference is not terrible, it's also not a slam dunk. You are building a cache for performance reasons. (I assume that your careful, empirical, realistic research into the performance characteristics of your application has convincingly demonstrated that a caching strategy is necessary in order to achieve acceptable performance; if that's not the case, then you are making these decisions prematurely.) Every cache has to have a POLICY about when it releases its resources, otherwise it's a memory leak.

How do you know that the GC policy and your policy are equivalent policies? The GC was not designed with your specific performance needs in mind. That is, it was designed to release resources that really are garbage, not to achieve any particular performance goal you've got in mind. By delegating the decision to the GC, you give up your ability to tune your cache policy to your performance needs.

Related questions

Get property value from string using reflection

I am trying implement the Data transformation using Reflection1 example in my code. The GetSourceValue function has a switch comparing various types, but I want to remove these types and properties and have GetSourceValue get the value of the property …

Read More
How do I get the path of the assembly the code is in?

Is there a way to get the path for the assembly in which the current code resides? I do not want the path of the calling assembly, just the one containing the code. Basically my unit test needs to read …

Read More
How to create a new object instance from a Type

One may not always know the Type of an object at compile-time, but may need to create an instance of the Type. How do you get a new object instance from a Type?

Read More