Choose between ArrayAdapter and SimpleAdapter

android android-arrayadapter simpleadapter
Cheok Yan Cheng picture Cheok Yan Cheng · Jun 18, 2011 · Viewed 7.9k times · Source

I was wondering, is there any guideline, on how we choose between ArrayAdapter and SimpleAdapter.

For every list item, they will be presented by several TextViews and Views, which is being layout nicely. I realize I can implement both without any problem, by either using ArrayAdapter or SimpleAdapter.

Is there any guideline, on how we choose among them? My guess is

  1. ArrayAdapter enables us to add in new item dynamically, even after the list is being shown during that time. Note that, ArrayAdapter is having method add.
  2. SimpleAdapter is used for case, once the list is being shown, there are no more new item can be added.

Is this the guideline we should follow?

Answer

CommonsWare picture CommonsWare · Jun 18, 2011

Personally, I don't find SimpleAdapter terribly useful. Your model data is rarely naturally in "an ArrayList of Maps", and it is wasteful to be copying stuff around just to get it in an adapter.

I would either use ArrayAdapter (if my model data is an array of objects) or BaseAdapter (if my model data is some other in-memory data structure).

Related questions

notifyDataSetChanged example

I'm trying to use in my Android Application the notifyDataSetChanged() method for an ArrayAdapter but it doesn't work for me. I found as answer here, that notifyDataSetChanged() should run in the main thread, but there was no example for that. …

Read More
What is "android.R.layout.simple_list_item_1"?

I've started learning Android development and am following a todolist example from a book: // Create the array list of to do items final ArrayList<String> todoItems = new ArrayList<String>(); // Create the array adapter to bind the …

Read More
ArrayAdapter in android to create simple listview

I tried to create an Activity in Android, This Activity only contains a ListView nothing else. As I know to fill the listview we need to use an ArrayAdapter. So to understand the ArrayAdapter I have read the following link: …

Read More