About Android Progress Dialog. Avoid?

android android-fragments android-alertdialog android-dialog android-progressbar
Hong Wei Wang picture Hong Wei Wang · Jan 16, 2014 · Viewed 10.7k times · Source

I was reading about Dialogs in Android site and I came across a section that saying "Avoid ProgressDialog".

Here is the link: http://developer.android.com/guide/topics/ui/dialogs.html

does that means they recommend not to use it? I really need a popup with showing progress while my app is doing background work.

Does that means I have to build my own Progress Dialog using ProgressBar class? How would one build it by the way? Any help is appreciated.

Answer

A--C picture A--C · Jan 16, 2014

Edit: With Android O, ProgressDialog is now officially deprecated. An alternative is approach is suggested

This class was deprecated in API level O. Use a progress indicator such as ProgressBar inline inside of an activity rather than using this modal dialog.

Original answer:

This is all from a design & user interaction perspective, not a code perspective.

The UI guidelines are telling you to avoid using a ProgressDialog not because the class is deprecated (it is not at the time of writing this answer), but rather because it forces the user to avoid interacting with the application and merely stare at the screen.

Take the Google Play app as an example. While it downloads an application/update, you can still swipe, navigate, etc. You can still be involved with the app while it is doing something.

If you absolutely need the user to cease interaction until the progress bar finishes, by all means do so. The docs are merely saying you may be able to find better ways of doing it (hence the link to Progress & Activity).

Related questions

How to use Dialog Fragment? (showDialog deprecated) Android

I understand that there is this documentation http://developer.android.com/reference/android/app/DialogFragment.html#AlertDialog but as a new Android/Java learner it is not easy to understand the amount of code involved from writing a simple alert …

Read More
Problem inflating custom view for AlertDialog in DialogFragment

I'm trying to create a DialogFragment using a custom view in an AlertDialog. This view must be inflated from xml. In my DialogFragment class I have: @Override public Dialog onCreateDialog(Bundle savedInstanceState) { return new AlertDialog.Builder(getActivity()) .setTitle("Title") .setView(…

Read More
Simplest yes/no dialog fragment

I'd like to make a dialog fragment that asks "Are you sure?" with a "yes/no" reply. I've looked at the documentation and it's really verbose, going all over the place, explaining how to make advanced dialog boxes, but no …

Read More