Saxon 9 XSLT transformer vs Xalan 2.7

xslt saxon xalan
Aditya picture Aditya · May 9, 2013 · Viewed 16k times · Source

I am currently using Xalan 2.7.0 for XSLT transformations over XML, but thinking over to switch to Saxon 9 version for XSLT transformations. So could someone list me the major cons and prons of using Saxon over Xalan . Although i know that Saxon supports XSLT 2.0 and other major changes but instead i would like to know more about personal experiences with Saxon 9 and its prons and cons and other benefits.

Answer

Dimitre Novatchev picture Dimitre Novatchev · May 10, 2013

I used Xalan 10 years ago. I have been using Saxon almost exclusively for the last 10 years.

Not only is Saxon an XSLT 2.0 and XSLT 3.0 processor, but it is very actively developed and maintained.

Saxon 9.xx is one of the fastest XSLT processors. Its developer, Dr. Michael Kay is the Editor of the W3C XSLT WG (Working Group) and thus he is probable the one that best understands the XSLT Specification and this shows in Saxon. Any language feature is strictly and precisely implemented -- usually well ahead of other vendors.

Dr. Kay often reports the level of compliance as indicated by running the W3C XSLT and XQuery WGs test suite, which consists of tens of thousands of tests.

Saxon is supported by several IDEs, one of the most prominent being oXygen. Saxon has a very active user mailing list and the typical response time is usually measured in hours.

While I have about 11 XSLT processors installed, the one that I am using 99% of my time is Saxon.

Related questions

Call Java instance methods in XSLT

I am using Saxon (I could use Xalan if necessary) XSLT processor to do some transformation. I want to pass the instance of below object to the XSLT template as parameter. public class Test { private String value; public Test(String …

Read More
How to execute XSLT 2.0 with ant?

I'm trying to run an XSLT transformation from an ant file. I'm using a XSLT 2.0 stylesheet with a saxon 9 parser (supporting XSLT 2.0). The problem is that it seems that ant is always calling an XSLT 1.0 parser. Here's my ant file : &…

Read More
How to run saxon xslt transformation in java

I can easily run the following in command line to transform an xml file: java -jar saxon9he.jar -o:outputfile.xml data.xml transform.xslt I would like to do the exact same results from within a java file …

Read More