Which version of MSXML should I use?

windows visual-c++ com scripting msxml
Cheeso picture Cheeso · Jun 4, 2009 · Viewed 23.6k times · Source

Seems like this would be a common question, though I could not find it on SO.

Which version of MSXML should I use in my applications, and more importantly, how should I decide?

There is MSXML3, 4, 5 and 6.

I recently posted some code in calling-wcf-service-by-vbscript that used MSXML v4. AnthonyWJones posted that I shouldn't use 4, but instead 3 or 6, but probably 3. Certainly not v5!

Why? I'd like to know more about the criteria for selecting the version of MSXML to use in my apps.

Bonus question: Does anyone have a summary of the differences between the various versions of MSXML over time?

Summary so far:

  • MSXML6
    Should be first choice. was released in 2006, and includes perf and compliance fixes. Use this if you can. It's good. There are no merge modules; to bundle the MSXML6 runtime with your app, MS suggests packaging the MSXML6 msi file. MSXML6 is an upgrade from MSXML3/4 but does not replace them, because it discontinues some features. You can get the MSI here.
  • MSXML3
    Second choice. Most widely deployed version. Originally shipped in March 2000. Actively maintained, no new features. Currently supported, if you are on SP5 (shipped in 2005) or later. SP7 is current (also from 2005).
  • MSXML5
    was released only as part of MS-Office. Currently supported by Microsoft, but only as part of Office, not for building apps. Don't build apps that depend on MSXML5: Verboten.
  • MSXML4
    originally shipped? Currently in "maintenance mode". Microsoft is encouraging people to move off MSXML4 to MSXML6. Currently supported if you are on MSXML4SP2 or later, which shipped in 2003. download MSXML4SP2 here. Can be redisributed.

Using the right version of MSXML in Internet Explorer is a good entry on the blog from Microsoft's xmlteam.

Answer

Shog9 picture Shog9 · Jun 4, 2009

If you need to support Windows OS versions prior to Win2k, then use MSXML3. Otherwise, use MSXML6.

MSXML4 is in maintenance mode.
MSXML5 was never actually supported for use outside of MS-Office.

See:

Related questions

CoCreateInstance returning E_NOINTERFACE even though interface is found

I have a COM class CMyCOMServer implementing IMyInterface in one application, both with correct GUIDs. CMyCOMServer::QueryInterface will return S_OK (and cast itself to the right type) if IUnknown or IMyInterface is requested, otherwise it returns E_NOINTERFACE. In …

Read More
How to best convert CString to BSTR to pass it as an "in" parameter into a COM method?

I need to convert a CString instance into a properly allocated BSTR and pass that BSTR into a COM method. To have code that compiles and works indentically for both ANSI and Unicode I use CString::AllocSysString() to convert whatever …

Read More
How can I see the interfaces of a ocx file?

I want to see the interfaces of an ".ocx" file. Like this: But for some .ocx, I can only see 5 functions, Like this: The question is: How can I see the interfaces of these ocx file. I have try this: …

Read More