What Vim features are missing in Emacs with Viper and Vimpulse?

vim emacs editor viper vimpulse
Alexey Romanov picture Alexey Romanov · Nov 29, 2008 · Viewed 7.8k times · Source

There are important features of Emacs which are missing in Vim, such as the comint mode, and there are no scripts/plugins which can replace them.

There are also benefits of Vim over Emacs, such as modal editing and generally better default shortcuts. However, Viper mode gets me both. Vimpulse also enables visual mode. Unfortunately, no mode can make Emacs work as fast as Vim.

So I mostly learned Vim-in-Emacs. What Vim features am I missing?

Answer

Michael picture Michael · Dec 1, 2008

I'm a regular vim user but not an emacs user and haven't used vimpulse to confirm this.

But browsing the vimpulse code below I see no mention of text objects.

http://www.emacswiki.org/cgi-bin/wiki/vimpulse.el

Vim introduced some very useful idioms for selection and movement that aren't in regular vi

  • cat 'cut around tag' for xml/html tags
  • diw 'delete in word'
  • di( di" delete text within a "" () etc.

in the vim help see :he text-objects for more.

Related questions

How do I make Git use the editor of my choice for commits?

I would prefer to write my commit messages in Vim, but it is opening them in Emacs. How do I configure Git to always use Vim? Note that I want to do this globally, not just for a single project.

Read More
Differences between Emacs and Vim

Without getting into a religious argument about why one is better than the other, what are the practical differences between Emacs and Vim? I'm looking to learn one or the other, but I realize the learning curve for each is …

Read More
Is it worth investing time in learning to use Emacs?

Right up front: I do not want to start a religious war. I've used vi for as long as I can remember, and the few times I've tried to pick up Emacs I've been so lost that I've quickly given …

Read More