Why is it not possible to fake an IP address?

tcp ip
Fluffy picture Fluffy · Mar 3, 2011 · Viewed 33.7k times · Source

I know it's possible to change an IP address using a proxy, but I'm interested in why is it not possible to change it by sending changed data from a single computer?

Update:

Thanks for quick replies, but it's not clear, what would happen, should a stateless protocol be used, like HTTP. I'm not familiar with lower-level network communication, but it seems that theoretically it should be possible to faken IP address if a PC connects to the server and receives the reply immediately.

Answer

Erik picture Erik · Mar 3, 2011

It is fully possible to send data with a fake sender IP. You'll have a hard time getting replies though, since the replies will be sent to the fake IP and never reach you. Additionally, if you send data with a "from" IP that a router doesn't expect to arrive from you, the router will often simply drop it, and sometimes inform the ISP that you're up to something that violates your TOS.

EDIT: In response to edited post.

Any protocol (such as HTTP) that is built on top of a connection-oriented protocol (TCP) will require a valid IP. The cases where fake IPs have been prevalent mostly involve Denial Of Service attacks, using UDP, ICMP or the initial SYN packet in a TCP handshake.

Related questions

Calculating range of IPs from subnet mask

Say, I have a subnet of 255.255.255.242 and I have a known IP within that subnet say 192.168.1.101. Now the way I calculate the range of IPs is this: In the subnet mask, find the first octet that is not a 255. In …

Read More
Are we using TCP/IP or OSI in internet?

sorry for that question, but i've searched about that topic, and it's not really clear, they say that internet uses tcp/ip but sometimes they say that osi also is used! for example, UDP application, they dont use tcp/ip …

Read More
Can I use broadcast or multicast for TCP?

For Internet Protocol (IP) I can use multicast: in IPv4: Internet Group Management Protocol (IGMP) in IPv6: Multicast Listener Discovery Also, in example, for UDP I can use: broadcast - to send packet to range of addresses multicast - to …

Read More