Difference between Struts 1 and Struts 2?

Nils picture Nils · Nov 4, 2011 · Viewed 31.1k times · Source

I had been using struts 2, but for few reasons i am shifting (back) to Struts 1 . I would like to know major diffrences between them like about programatic availabilities and general flows.

Answer

Ashwini picture Ashwini · Nov 21, 2012

Let us see the component and functional differences between struts 1.x and struts 2.x

 In struts 1.x front controller is ActionServlet
    In 2.x front controller is FilterDispatcher

In struts 1.x we have RequestProcessor class
    In 2.x we have Interceptors instead RequestProcessor will see about this concept later just remember as of now

In struts 1.x we have multiple tag libraries like, html, logic, bean..etc
    In 2.x we do not have multiple libraries, instead we have single library which includes all tags

In struts 1.x the configuration fine name can be [any name].xml and we used to place in web-inf folder
    In 2.x the configuration file must be struts.xml only and this must be in classes folder

In struts 1.x we have form beans and Action classes separately
    In 2.x form bean, Action classes are combinedly given as Action class only, of course we can take separately if we want ;)

In struts 1.x properties file must be configured in struts-config.xml
    But in 2.x we need to configure our resource bundle(s) in struts.properties file

In struts 1.x we have programmatic and declarative validations only
    In 2.x we have annotations support too along with programmatic and declarative validations

Functional Differences

In struts 1.x declarative validations are done by using validation frame work
    In 2.x, declarative validations are done by using xwork2 frame work by webwork the reason being, its support valuations through Annotations

In struts 1.x an Action class is a single ton class, so Action class object is not a thread safe, as a programmer we need to make it as thread safe by applying synchronization
    In 2.x an Action class object will be created for each request, so it is by default thread safe, so we no need to take care about safety issues here

In struts 1.x we have only jsp as a view technology
    In 2.x we have support of multiple view technologies like velocity, Freemarker, jasper reports, jsp bla bla

In struts 1.x Action class is having servlet dependency, because in execute() method accepts req, res parameter right ! so.
    In 2.x Action class doesn’t have any servlet dependency, because its execute() method doesn’t accepts any parameters, however we can access all servlet objects with dependency injection