Media streaming basics - HTTP vs RTMP

streaming red5 rtmp xuggle
WinOrWin picture WinOrWin · Apr 30, 2011 · Viewed 19.2k times · Source

I am very new to media streaming, and I have some basic doubts to clear :

  1. As far as I can understand, the difference between HTTP streaming (say through Apache) and a RTMP streaming (through Red5) is that streaming servers provide buffering and advance controls like seek, etc. Am I right ?

  2. Can I stream only flash videos from RTMP servers like Red5 ? If I have to stream varying formats of files, do I have to go for HTTP streaming ? Can I use tools like xuggler to dynamically transcode files and send according to the request from the Red5 server ?

I am posing all these doubts because I have to provide streaming to all mobile clients - iPhone, Blackberry, Android - iPhone does not support flash, so is it a good idea to go for Red5 ?

Answer

Max Lapshin picture Max Lapshin · Jun 3, 2011

Let me be a bit verbose to clear details.

1) What is "streaming". Usually in world of video streaming is delivery of frames according to realtime. If you have 30-minutes video it will be delivered to user in 30 minutes.

There are special protocols dedicated exclusively for streaming: RTSP (perhaps the ancient of living today), RTMP, MJPEG, family of http-based protocols (apple,abobe,microsoft) and some other closed vendor protocols.

2) what is "http-streaming" or "pseudo-streaming". If you just put your file on HTTP server, user can download it and watch. If he downloads full video, he can even seek in it. But what happens if user want to seek to the middle of film without downloading first part? It should somehow tell to server: open file container, seek to this moment and pack file back. So HTTP server must know about structure of file container to deliver seek functionality to client.

nginx and apache can do it for flv and mp4 containers, which is ok for 100% of video, possible to play via Flash Player.

3) what is http-streaming messed with nowadays. Apple, Adobe and microsoft has designed and implemented streaming on top of HTTP. It means that client downloads 10-seconds segment, still keeping proper framerate. 30-minutes film is still downloaded in 30 minutes, but there are big delays between segment downloadings. It is possible to seek in such "format", to switch bitrates, etc.

4) RTMP Streaming servers like Red5 or erlyvideo can stream H.264, H.263, VP6 and Screen video. MPEG-4 (Xvid/DivX) or MPEG-2 is not supported.

Related questions

Wireshark doesnt' recognises RTMP streams

I found on the web few samples on tracking RTMP (Real Time Messaging Protocol) with Wireshark, but it doesn't work for me. All RTMPT packets rendered as basic TCP packet like this: 149 14.324999 85.115.xxx.xxx 192.168.1.20 TCP macromedia-fcs > 54557 [ACK] Seq=1 Ack=1452 …

Read More
Streaming via RTSP or RTP in HTML5

I'm building a web app that should play back an RTSP/RTP stream from a server http://lscube.org/projects/feng. Does the HTML5 video/audio tag support the rtsp or rtp? If not, what would the easiest solution be? …

Read More
Download/Stream file from URL - asp.net

I need to stream a file which will result in save as prompt in the browser. The issue is, the directory that the file is located is virtually mapped, so I am unable to use Server.MapPath to determine it's …

Read More