Both left and right aliases encountered in Hive JOIN; without any inequality clause

Question

I am using following query:

Select
   S.MDSE_ITEM_I,
   S.CO_LOC_I,
   MAX(S.SLS_D) as MAX_SLS_D,
   MIN(S.SLS_D) as MIN_SLS_D,
   sum(S.SLS_UNIT_Q) as SLS_UNIT_Q,
   MIN(PRSMN_VAL_STRT_D) as PRSMN_VAL_STRT_D,
   MIN(PRSMN_VAL_END_D) as PRSMN_VAL_END_D,
   MIN(RC.FRST_RCPT_D) as FRST_RCPT_D,
   MIN(RC.CURR_ACTV_FRST_OH_D) as CURR_ACTV_FRST_OH_D,
   MIN(H.GREG_D) as  OH_GREG_D  
from
   eefe_lstr4.SLS_TBL as S  
left outer join
   eefe_lstr4.PRS_TBL P 
      on S.MDSE_ITEM_I = P.MDSE_ITEM_I 
      and S.CO_LOC_I = P.CO_LOC_I 
      and S.SLS_D between PRSMN_VAL_STRT_D and PRSMN_VAL_END_D  
left outer join
   eefe_lstr4.OROW_RCPT RC 
      on RC.MDSE_ITEM_I =S.MDSE_ITEM_I 
      and RC.CO_LOC_I =  S.CO_LOC_I  
left outer join
   eefe_lstr4.OH H 
      on H.MDSE_ITEM_I =S.MDSE_ITEM_I 
      and H.CO_LOC_I = S.CO_LOC_I  
group by
   S.MDSE_ITEM_I,
   S.CO_LOC_I;

I am getting error saying:

FAILED: SemanticException Line 0:-1 Both left and right aliases encountered in JOIN 'PRSMN_VAL_END_D'

Search shows that this error comes when you have inequality clause in query. However I am not using any inequality clause (<= or >= in my query (just = and between) even then I am getting this error.

Answer 1

Try to move the inequality condition from on clause to the where condition .

Select S.MDSE_ITEM_I,S.CO_LOC_I,
       MAX(S.SLS_D) as MAX_SLS_D,
       MIN(S.SLS_D) as MIN_SLS_D,
       sum(S.SLS_UNIT_Q) as SLS_UNIT_Q,
       MIN(PRSMN_VAL_STRT_D) as PRSMN_VAL_STRT_D,
       MIN(PRSMN_VAL_END_D) as PRSMN_VAL_END_D,
       MIN(RC.FRST_RCPT_D) as FRST_RCPT_D,
       MIN(RC.CURR_ACTV_FRST_OH_D) as CURR_ACTV_FRST_OH_D,
       MIN(H.GREG_D) as  OH_GREG_D
from eefe_lstr4.SLS_TBL as S
         left outer join eefe_lstr4.PRS_TBL P on S.MDSE_ITEM_I = P.MDSE_ITEM_I and S.CO_LOC_I = P.CO_LOC_I 
         left outer join eefe_lstr4.OROW_RCPT RC on RC.MDSE_ITEM_I =S.MDSE_ITEM_I and RC.CO_LOC_I =  S.CO_LOC_I
         left outer join eefe_lstr4.OH H on H.MDSE_ITEM_I =S.MDSE_ITEM_I and H.CO_LOC_I = S.CO_LOC_I
where(S.SLS_D between PRSMN_VAL_STRT_D and PRSMN_VAL_END_D)
group by S.MDSE_ITEM_I, S.CO_LOC_I;