Entity Framework: How to properly handle exceptions that occur due to SQL constraints

Question

I use Entity Framework to access my SQL data. I have some constraints in the database schema and I wonder how to handle exceptions that are caused by these constraints.

As example, I get the following exception in a case where two users try to add an (almost) identical entity to the DB concurrently.

System.Data.UpdateException
"An error occurred while updating the entries. See the InnerException for details."

(inner exception) System.Data.SqlClient.SqlException
"Violation of UNIQUE KEY constraint 'Unique_GiftId'. Cannot insert duplicate key in object 'dbo.Donations'.\r\nThe statement has been terminated."

How do I properly catch this specific exception?

Dirty solution:

    catch (UpdateException ex)
    {
        SqlException innerException = ex.InnerException as SqlException;
        if (innerException != null && innerException.Message.StartsWith("Violation of UNIQUE KEY constraint 'Unique_GiftId'"))
        {
            // handle exception here..
        }
        else
        {
            throw;
        }
    }

Now while this approach works, it has some downsides:

• No type safety: The code depends on the exception message which contains the name of the unique column.
• Dependency on the SqlCLient classes (broken abstraction)

Do you know a better solution for this? Thanks for all feedback..

Note: I do not want to code the constraints manually within the application layer, I want to have them in the DB.

Answer 1

You should be able to trap the SQL error number (which is SqlException.Number)

In this case it's 2627 which has been the same forever for SQL Server.

If you want abstraction, then you'll always have some dependency on the database engine because each one will throw different exception numbers and messages.