Select one column DISTINCT SQL

Organiccat picture Organiccat · Oct 30, 2008 · Viewed 58.5k times · Source

Added: Working with SQL Server 2000 and 2005, so has to work on both. Also, value_rk is not a number/integer (Error: Operand data type uniqueidentifier is invalid for min operator)

Is there a way to do a single column "DISTINCT" match when I don't care about the other columns returned? Example:

**Table**
Value A, Value L, Value P
Value A, Value Q, Value Z

I need to return only one of these rows based on what is in the first one (Value A). I still need results from the second and third columns (the second should actually match all across the board anyway, but the third is a unique key, which I need at least one of).

Here's what I've got so far, although it doesn't work obviously:

SELECT value, attribute_definition_id, value_rk
FROM attribute_values
WHERE value IN (
    SELECT value, max(value_rk)
    FROM attribute_values
)
ORDER BY attribute_definition_id

I'm working in ColdFusion so if there's a simple workaround in that I'm open to that as well. I'm trying to limit or "group by" the first column "value". value_rk is my big problem since every value is unique but I only need one.

NOTE: value_rk is not a number, hence this DOES NOT WORK

UPDATE: I've got a working version, it's probably quite a bit slower than a pure SQL version, but honestly anything working at this point is better than nothing. It takes the results from the first query, does a second query except limiting it's results to one, and grabs a matching value_rk for the value that matches. Like so:

<cfquery name="queryBaseValues" datasource="XXX" timeout="999">
    SELECT DISTINCT value, attribute_definition_id
    FROM attribute_values
    ORDER BY attribute_definition_id
</cfquery>

<cfoutput query="queryBaseValues">
    <cfquery name="queryRKValue" datasource="XXX">
        SELECT TOP 1 value_rk
        FROM attribute_values
        WHERE value = '#queryBaseValues.value#'
    </cfquery>
    <cfset resourceKey = queryRKValue.value_rk>
    ...

So there you have it, selecting a single column distinctly in ColdFusion. Any pure SQL Server 2000/2005 suggestions are still very welcome :)

Answer

walming picture walming · Oct 30, 2008

this might work:

SELECT DISTINCT a.value, a.attribute_definition_id, 
  (SELECT TOP 1 value_rk FROM attribute_values WHERE value = a.value) as value_rk
FROM attribute_values as a
ORDER BY attribute_definition_id

.. not tested.