How do I create a comma-separated list using a SQL query?

leora picture leora · Nov 30, 2009 · Viewed 171k times · Source

I have 3 tables called:

  • Applications (id, name)
  • Resources (id, name)
  • ApplicationsResources (id, app_id, resource_id)

I want to show on a GUI a table of all resource names. In one cell in each row I would like to list out all of the applications (comma separated) of that resource.

So the question is, what is the best way to do this in SQL as I need to get all resources and I also need to get all applications for each resource?

Do I run a select * from resources first and then loop through each resource and do a separate query per resource to get the list of applications for that resource?

Is there a way I can do this in one query?

Answer

OMG Ponies picture OMG Ponies · Nov 30, 2009

MySQL

  SELECT r.name,
         GROUP_CONCAT(a.name SEPARATOR ',')
    FROM RESOURCES r
    JOIN APPLICATIONSRESOURCES ar ON ar.resource_id = r.id
    JOIN APPLICATIONS a ON a.id = ar.app_id
GROUP BY r.name

SQL Server (2005+)

SELECT r.name,
       STUFF((SELECT ','+ a.name
               FROM APPLICATIONS a
               JOIN APPLICATIONRESOURCES ar ON ar.app_id = a.id
              WHERE ar.resource_id = r.id
           GROUP BY a.name
            FOR XML PATH(''), TYPE).value('.','VARCHAR(max)'), 1, 1, '')
 FROM RESOURCES r

SQL Server (2017+)

  SELECT r.name,
         STRING_AGG(a.name, ',')
    FROM RESOURCES r
    JOIN APPLICATIONSRESOURCES ar ON ar.resource_id = r.id
    JOIN APPLICATIONS a ON a.id = ar.app_id
GROUP BY r.name

Oracle

I recommend reading about string aggregation/concatentation in Oracle.