What do you use when you need reliable UDP?

sockets tcp network-programming udp
Len Holgate picture Len Holgate · Sep 20, 2008 · Viewed 66k times · Source

If you have a situation where a TCP connection is potentially too slow and a UDP 'connection' is potentially too unreliable what do you use? There are various standard reliable UDP protocols out there, what experiences do you have with them?

Please discuss one protocol per reply and if someone else has already mentioned the one you use then consider voting them up and using a comment to elaborate if required.

I'm interested in the various options here, of which TCP is at one end of the scale and UDP is at the other. Various reliable UDP options are available and each brings some elements of TCP to UDP.

I know that often TCP is the correct choice but having a list of the alternatives is often useful in helping one come to that conclusion. Things like Enet, RUDP, etc that are built on UDP have various pros and cons, have you used them, what are your experiences?

For the avoidance of doubt there is no more information, this is a hypothetical question and one that I hoped would elicit a list of responses that detailed the various options and alternatives available to someone who needs to make a decision.

Answer

philant picture philant · Sep 20, 2008

What about SCTP. It's a standard protocol by the IETF (RFC 4960)

It has chunking capability which could help for speed.

Update: a comparison between TCP and SCTP shows that the performances are comparable unless two interfaces can be used.

Update: a nice introductory article.

Related questions

What is "backlog" in TCP connections?

Below, you see a python program that acts as a server listening for connection requests to port 9999: # server.py import socket import time # create a socket object serversocket = socket.socket( socket.AF_INET, socket.SOCK_STREAM) # get local machine name …

Read More
TCP: can two different sockets share a port?

This might be a very basic question but it confuses me. Can two different connected sockets share a port? I'm writing an application server that should be able to handle more than 100k concurrent connections, and we know that the …

Read More
Why is bind() used in TCP? Why is it used only on server side and not in client side?

I wanted to know the exact function of bind() in TCP. What does it mean by 'binding' a local address to the socket? If it's assigning a port number to the socket, then why don't we use it in the …

Read More