Is Ruby really an interpreted language if all of its implementations are compiled into bytecode?

ruby interpreter interpreted-language compiled-language
Paul Dexter picture Paul Dexter · Apr 4, 2009 · Viewed 12.4k times · Source

In the chosen answer for this question about Blue Ruby, Chuck says:

All of the current Ruby implementations are compiled to bytecode. Contrary to SAP's claims, as of Ruby 1.9, MRI itself includes a bytecode compiler, though the ability to save the compiled bytecode to disk disappeared somewhere in the process of merging the YARV virtual machine. JRuby is compiled into Java .class files. I don't have a lot of details on MagLev, but it seems safe to say it will take that road as well.

I'm confused about this compilation/interpretation issue with respect to Ruby.

I learned that Ruby is an interpreted language and that's why when I save changes to my Ruby files I don't need to re-build the project.

But if all of the Ruby implementations now are compiled, is it still fair to say that Ruby is an interpreted language? Or am I misunderstanding something?

Answer

Steven Huwig picture Steven Huwig · Apr 4, 2009

Nearly every language is "compiled" nowadays, if you count bytecode as being compiled. Even Emacs Lisp is compiled. Ruby was a special case because until recently, it wasn't compiled into bytecode.

I think you're right to question the utility of characterizing languages as "compiled" vs. "interpreted." One useful distinction, though, is whether the language creates machine code (e.g. x86 assembler) directly from user code. C, C++, many Lisps, and Java with JIT enabled do, but Ruby, Python, and Perl do not.

People who don't know better will call any language that has a separate manual compilation step "compiled" and ones that don't "interpreted."

Related questions

Where is the Ruby interpreter located?

I'm using Ruby 1.8.7 on OS X. Where is the Ruby interpreter located? My goal is to learn more about Ruby, interpreted languages and interpreting/parsing.

Read More
Measure and Benchmark Time for Ruby Methods

How can i measure the time taken by a method and the individual statements in that method in Ruby. If you see the below method i want to measure the total time taken by the method and the time taken …

Read More
How to check if a value exists in an array in Ruby

I have a value 'Dog' and an array ['Cat', 'Dog', 'Bird']. How do I check if it exists in the array without looping through it? Is there a simple way of checking if the value exists, nothing more?

Read More