What's the difference between identical(x, y) and isTRUE(all.equal(x, y))?

r comparison equality built-in floating-point-comparison
mariotomo picture mariotomo · Aug 3, 2010 · Viewed 16.7k times · Source

Is there any difference between testing isTRUE(all.equal(x, y)) and identical(x, y)?

The help page says:

Don't use 'all.equal' directly in 'if' expressions — either use 'isTRUE(all.equal(....))' or 'identical' if appropriate.

but that "if appropriate" leaves me in doubt. How do I decide which of the two is appropriate?

Answer

Joshua Ulrich picture Joshua Ulrich · Aug 3, 2010

all.equal tests for near equality, while identical is more exact (e.g. it has no tolerance for differences, and it compares storage type). From ?identical:

The function ‘all.equal’ is also sometimes used to test equality this way, but was intended for something different: it allows for small differences in numeric results.

And one reason you would wrap all.equal in isTRUE is because all.equal will report differences rather than simply return FALSE.

Related questions

Numeric comparison difficulty in R

I'm trying to compare two numbers in R as a part of a if-statement condition: (a-b) >= 0.5 In this particular instance, a = 0.58 and b = 0.08... and yet (a-b) >= 0.5 is false. I'm aware of the dangers of using == for exact number …

Read More
No applicable method for 'anti_join' applied to an object of class "factor"

I want to Identify the rows present in dataframe1 which are not present in dataframe2 based on a particular column. I have used the below code to get the desired information. diffId <- anti_join(dat$ID,datwe$ID) …

Read More
How to compare boolean vectors in R

I have a vector v and I want to find all those elements, that have values between 4 and 7. v = c(1:9) # indices of elements with values larger than 4 which(v > 4) # indices of elements with values smaller than 7 which(v < 7) …

Read More