No Multiline Lambda in Python: Why not?

python syntax lambda
Imagist picture Imagist · Aug 5, 2009 · Viewed 196.7k times · Source

I've heard it said that multiline lambdas can't be added in Python because they would clash syntactically with the other syntax constructs in Python. I was thinking about this on the bus today and realized I couldn't think of a single Python construct that multiline lambdas clash with. Given that I know the language pretty well, this surprised me.

Now, I'm sure Guido had a reason for not including multiline lambdas in the language, but out of curiosity: what's a situation where including a multiline lambda would be ambiguous? Is what I've heard true, or is there some other reason that Python doesn't allow multiline lambdas?

Answer

Eli Courtwright picture Eli Courtwright · Aug 5, 2009

Guido van Rossum (the inventor of Python) answers this exact question himself in an old blog post.
Basically, he admits that it's theoretically possible, but that any proposed solution would be un-Pythonic:

"But the complexity of any proposed solution for this puzzle is immense, to me: it requires the parser (or more precisely, the lexer) to be able to switch back and forth between indent-sensitive and indent-insensitive modes, keeping a stack of previous modes and indentation level. Technically that can all be solved (there's already a stack of indentation levels that could be generalized). But none of that takes away my gut feeling that it is all an elaborate Rube Goldberg contraption."

Related questions

Which is more preferable to use: lambda functions or nested functions ('def')?

I mostly use lambda functions but sometimes use nested functions that seem to provide the same behavior. Here are some trivial examples where they functionally do the same thing if either were found within another function: Lambda function >>&…

Read More
How can I do a line break (line continuation) in Python?

I have a long line of code that I want to break up among multiple lines. What do I use and what is the syntax? For example, adding a bunch of strings, e = 'a' + 'b' + 'c' + 'd' and have it …

Read More
Putting a simple if-then-else statement on one line

I'm just getting into Python and I really like the terseness of the syntax. However, is there an easier way of writing an if-then-else statement so it fits on one line? For example: if count == N: count = 0 else: count = N + 1 …

Read More