How to specify the parent query field from within a subquery in mySQL?

justinl picture justinl · Dec 29, 2009 · Viewed 76k times · Source

Is there a way to specify the parent query field from within a subquery in mySQL?

For Example:
I have written a basic Bulletin Board type program in PHP.

In the database each post contains: id(PK) and parent_id(the id of the parent post). If the post is itself a parent, then its parent_id is set to 0.

I am trying to write a mySQL query that will find every parent post and the number of children that the parent has.

$query = "SELECT id, (
      SELECT COUNT(1) 
      FROM post_table 
      WHERE parent_id = id
) as num_children
FROM post_table
WHERE parent_id = 0";

The tricky part is that the first id doesn't know that it should be referring to the second id that is outside of the subquery. I know that I can do SELECT id AS id_tmp and then refer to it inside the subquery, but then if I want to also return the id and keep "id" as the column name, then I'd have to do a query that returns me 2 columns with the same data (which seems messy to me)

$query = "SELECT id, id AS id_tmp, 
            (SELECT COUNT(1)
            FROM post_table
            WHERE parent_id = id_tmp) as num_children
         FROM post_table
         WHERE parent_id = 0";

The messy way works fine, but I feel an opportunity to learn something here so I thought I'd post the question.

Answer

Don picture Don · Dec 29, 2009

How about:

$query = "SELECT p1.id, 
                 (SELECT COUNT(1) 
                    FROM post_table p2 
                   WHERE p2.parent_id = p1.id) as num_children
            FROM post_table p1
           WHERE p1.parent_id = 0";

or if you put an alias on the p1.id, you might say:

$query = "SELECT p1.id as p1_id, 
                 (SELECT COUNT(1) 
                    FROM post_table p2 
                   WHERE p2.parent_id = p1.id) as num_children
            FROM post_table p1
           WHERE p1.parent_id = 0";