PHP: Why isn't exec() returning output?

php exec ping
Edward picture Edward · May 21, 2013 · Viewed 92.7k times · Source

I'm writing a PHP script to be used to check for network connections with Linux shell command ping calling it with PHP's exec():

<?php


// Bad IP domain for testing.
$domain_bad = "lksjdflksjdf.com";

$ip_address = $domain_bad;

exec("ping -c 1 $domain_bad", $output, $return_var);

var_dump($return_var);
echo "return_var is: $return_var" . "\n";
var_dump($output);


exit;
?>

I'm not getting the output for the error message from ping in $output which is what I'm expecting:

$ php try.php
ping: unknown host lksjdflksjdf.com
int(2)
return_var is: 2
array(0) {
}

If the domain is a good domain, such as yahoo.com, then $output has the output from ping in an array. But if it's an error such as 'ping: unknown host lksjdflksjdf.com' it doesn't get returned to the $output array.

Why is this happening and is there a better method to do this?

Answer

Hariprasad picture Hariprasad · May 21, 2013

You should redirect stderr to stdout.

To do that, change your exec() call like this:

exec("ping -c 1 $domain_bad 2>&1", $output, $return_var);

More info about 2>&1 meaning here.

Related questions

PHP shell_exec() vs exec()

I'm struggling to understand the difference between shell_exec() and exec()... I've always used exec() to execute server side commands, when would I use shell_exec()? Is shell_exec() just a shorthand for exec()? It seems to be the same …

Read More
Running a Python script from PHP

I'm trying to run a Python script from PHP using the following command: exec('/usr/bin/python2.7 /srv/http/assets/py/switch.py arg1 arg2'); However, PHP simply doesn't produce any output. Error reporting is set to E_…

Read More
PHP exec() vs system() vs passthru()

What are the differences? Is there a specific situation or reason for each function? If yes, can you give some examples of those situations? PHP.net says that they are used to execute external programs. see reference From the examples …

Read More