Which is faster/better for caching, File System or Memcached?

performance caching filesystems memcached
Lance Pollard picture Lance Pollard · Jun 30, 2010 · Viewed 25.5k times · Source

I don't think it's clear to me yet, is it faster to read things from a file or from memcached? Why?

Answer

gblazex picture gblazex · Jun 30, 2010

Memcached is faster, but the memory is limited. HDD is huge, but I/O is slow compared to memory. You should put the hottest things to memcached, and all the others can go to cache files.
(Or man up and invest some money into more memory like these guys :)

For some benchmarks see: Cache Performance Comparison (File, Memcached, Query Cache, APC)

In theory:

Read 1 MB sequentially from memory       250,000 ns
Disk seek                             10,000,000 ns

http://www.cs.cornell.edu/projects/ladis2009/talks/dean-keynote-ladis2009.pdf

Related questions

How to clear APC cache entries?

I need to clear all APC cache entries when I deploy a new version of the site. APC.php has a button for clearing all opcode caches, but I don't see buttons for clearing all User Entries, or all System …

Read More
What is a "cache-friendly" code?

What is the difference between "cache unfriendly code" and the "cache friendly" code? How can I make sure I write cache-efficient code?

Read More
MySQL query caching: limited to a maximum cache size of 128 MB?

My application is very database intensive so I've tried really hard to make sure the application and the MySQL database are working as efficiently as possible together. Currently I'm tuning the MySQL query cache to get it in line with …

Read More