dispatch_sync on main queue hangs in unit test

objective-c grand-central-dispatch sentestingkit
Drewsmits picture Drewsmits · Oct 19, 2011 · Viewed 20.9k times · Source

I was having some trouble unit testing some grand central dispatch code with the built in Xcode unit testing framework, SenTestingKit. I managed to boil my problem done to this. I have a unit test that builds a block and tries to execute it on the main thread. However, the block is never actually executed, so the test hangs because it's a synchronous dispatch.

- (void)testSample {

    dispatch_sync(dispatch_get_main_queue(), ^(void) {
        NSLog(@"on main thread!");
    });

    STFail(@"FAIL!");
}

What is it about the testing environment that causes this to hang?

Answer

BJ Homer picture BJ Homer · Oct 19, 2011

dispatch_sync runs a block on a given queue and waits for it to complete. In this case, the queue is the main dispatch queue. The main queue runs all its operations on the main thread, in FIFO (first-in-first-out) order. That means that whenever you call dispatch_sync, your new block will be put at the end of the line, and won't run until everything else before it in the queue is done.

The problem here is that the block you just enqueued is at the end of the line waiting to run on the main thread—while the testSample method is currently running on the main thread. The block at the end of the queue can't get access to the main thread until the current method (itself) finishes using the main thread. However dispatch_sync means Submits a block object for execution on a dispatch queue and waits until that block completes.

Related questions

Pattern for unit testing async queue that calls main queue on completion

This is related to my previous question, but different enough that I figured I'd throw it into a new one. I have some code that runs async on a custom queue, then executes a completion block on the main thread …

Read More
How do you trigger a block after a delay, like -performSelector:withObject:afterDelay:?

Is there a way to call a block with a primitive parameter after a delay, like using performSelector:withObject:afterDelay: but with an argument like int/double/float?

Read More
dispatch_after - GCD in Swift?

I've gone through the iBook from Apple, and couldn't find any definition of it: Can someone explain the structure of dispatch_after? dispatch_after(<#when: dispatch_time_t#>, <#queue: dispatch_queue_t?#>, <#block: dispatch_block_…

Read More