I am making a database of students in one school.Here is what I have so far:
If you don't like reading jump to the "In short" part
The problem is that I'm not happy with this design. I want the combination of grade
, subgrade
and id_class
to be unique and to serve as a primary key for the students table.
I can remove the student_id
and make a composite key from the 3 but I don't want that either. Maybe I should make another table lets say combination_id
where grade
, subgrade
and id_class
are foreign keys and there is one extra column comb_id
that serves as ID for the table. And all the columns will be Primary Keys. But the problem is that those 3 columns can still repeat because of that extra column (comb_id
). For example I can have the same grade
, subgrade
and class_id
but different comb_id
which will make the row valid because of the composite key of the 4 columns of the table (combination_id
).
In short I want students_id
to remain the only primary key of the table but to be a foreign key to another table which is somehow unique combination of grades
, subgrade
and class_id
.
If I was not clear enough ask in the comments below and thank you in advance.
PS I'm sorry for the indescriptive title but I'm bad at naming
EDIT 1:
To be more clear:
grade
can be 1 to 12
subgrade
can be a to j
id_class
can be 1 to 30 and it is your number in class
So a student can be from 7b class and his number in class - 5
Don't mix the concepts of unique keys and primary keys. You can very well add a unique key spanning the three columns grades
, subgrade
and class_id
. That way, no two rows could have the same values for these three columns. As you write that you don't want to have these three as a composite primary key, I'm not sure whether a composite unique supplemental key would be any better. If not, you'll have to clarify when composite keys are acceptable.
To create a unique key, you can use the following SQL statement:
ALTER TABLE students ADD UNIQUE gsc (grades, subgrade, class_id);
The word gsc
there is just a name I made up from the initials of the key columns; use whatever name you want, as it hardly matters unless you want to identify the key in some EXPLAIN
output or similar.