Shell: redirect stdout to /dev/null and stderr to stdout

Shou Ya picture Shou Ya · Aug 19, 2012 · Viewed 58.2k times · Source

I saw this interesting question at a comment on cyberciti.biz.

That I found I even can't find a flexible way to do this in one-line command with sh.

As far my thought for the solution is:

tmp_file=`mktemp`
(./script 2>$tmp_file >/dev/null; cat $tmp_file) | ./other-script
rm tmp_file

But you see, this is not synchronous, and fatally, it's so ugly.

Welcome to share you mind about this. :)

Answer

geirha picture geirha · Aug 19, 2012

You want

./script 2>&1 1>/dev/null | ./other-script

The order here is important. Let's assume stdin (fd 0), stdout (fd 1) and stderr (fd 2) are all connected to a tty initially, so

0: /dev/tty, 1: /dev/tty, 2: /dev/tty

The first thing that gets set up is the pipe. other-script's stdin gets connected to the pipe, and script's stdout gets connected to the pipe, so script's file descriptors so far look like:

0: /dev/tty, 1: pipe, 2: /dev/tty

Next, the redirections occur, from left to right. 2>&1 makes fd 2 go wherever fd 1 is currently going, which is the pipe.

0: /dev/tty, 1: pipe, 2: pipe

Lastly, 1>/dev/null redirects fd1 to /dev/null

0: /dev/tty, 1: /dev/null, 2: pipe

End result, script's stdout is silenced, and its stderr is sent through the pipe, which ends up in other-script's stdin.

Also see http://bash-hackers.org/wiki/doku.php/howto/redirection_tutorial

Also note that 1>/dev/null is synonymous to, but more explicit than >/dev/null