How do you refactor a large messy codebase?
I have a big mess of code. Admittedly, I wrote it myself - a year ago. It's not well commented but it's not very complicated either, so I can understand it -- just not well enough to know where to start as far as refactoring it.
I violated every rule that I have read about over the past year. There are classes with multiple responsibilities, there are indirect accesses (I forget the term - something like foo.bar.doSomething()), and like I said it is not well commented. On top of that, it's the beginnings of a game, so the graphics is coupled with the data, or the places where I tried to decouple graphics and data, I made the data public in order for the graphics to be able to access the data it needs...
It's a huge mess! Where do I start? How would you start on something like this?
My current approach is to take variables and switch them to private and then refactor the pieces that break, but that doesn't seem to be enough. Please suggest other strategies for wading through this mess and turning it into something clean so that I can continue where I left off!
Update two days later: I have been drawing out UML-like diagrams of my classes, and catching some of the "Low Hanging Fruit" along the way. I've even found some bits of code that were the beginnings of new features, but as I'm trying to slim everything down, I've been able to delete those bits and make the project feel cleaner. I'm probably going to refactor as much as possible before rigging my test cases (but only the things that are 100% certain not to impact the functionality, of course!), so that I won't have to refactor test cases as I change functionality. (do you think I'm doing it right or would it, in your opinion, be easier for me to suck it up and write the tests first?)
Please vote for the best answer so that I can mark it fairly! Feel free to add your own answer to the bunch as well, there's still room for you! I'll give it another day or so and then probably mark the highest-voted answer as accepted.
Thanks to everyone who has responded so far!
June 25, 2010: I discovered a blog post which directly answers this question from someone who seems to have a pretty good grasp of programming: (or maybe not, if you read his article :) )
To that end, I do four things when I need to refactor code:
- Determine what the purpose of the code was
- Draw UML and action diagrams of the classes involved
- Shop around for the right design patterns
- Determine clearer names for the current classes and methods
Answer
Pick yourself up a copy of Martin Fowler's Refactoring. It has some good advice on ways to break down your refactoring problem. About 75% of the book is little cookbook-style refactoring steps you can do. It also advocates automated unit tests that you can run after each step to prove your code still works.
As for a place to start, I would sit down and draw out a high-level architecture of your program. You don't have to get fancy with detailed UML models, but some basic UML is not a bad idea. You need a big picture idea of how the major pieces fit together so you can visually see where your decoupling is going to happen. Just a page or two of some basic block diagrams will help with the overwhelming feeling you have right now.
Without some sort of high level spec or design, you just risk getting lost again and ending up with another unmaintainable mess.
If you need to start from scratch, remember that you never truly start from scratch. You have some code and the knowledge you gained from your first time. But sometimes it does help to start with a blank project and pull things in as you go, rather than put out fires in a messy code base. Just remember not to completely throw out the old, use it for its good parts and pull them in as you go.