When is the comma operator useful?

javascript comma-operator
gdoron is supporting Monica picture gdoron is supporting Monica · Mar 6, 2012 · Viewed 31.4k times · Source

I read this question about the "comma operator" in expressions (,) and the MDN docs about it, but I can't think of a scenario where it is useful.

So, when is the comma operator useful?

Answer

pimvdb picture pimvdb · Mar 6, 2012

The following is probably not very useful as you don't write it yourself, but a minifier can shrink code using the comma operator. For example:

if(x){foo();return bar()}else{return 1}

would become:

return x?(foo(),bar()):1

The ? : operator can be used now, since the comma operator (to a certain extent) allows for two statements to be written as one statement.

This is useful in that it allows for some neat compression (39 -> 24 bytes here).

I'd like to stress the fact that the comma in var a, b is not the comma operator because it doesn't exist within an expression. The comma has a special meaning in var statements. a, b in an expression would be referring to the two variables and evaluate to b, which is not the case for var a, b.

Related questions

Javascript "tuple" notation: what is its point?

At wtfjs, I found that the following is legal javascript. ",,," == Array((null,'cool',false,NaN,4)); // true The argument (null,'cool',false,NaN,4) looks like a tuple to me, but javascript does not have tuples! Some quick tests in my javascript …

Read More
What does a comma do in JavaScript expressions?

If I use: 1.09 * 1; // returns "1.09" But if I use: 1,09 * 1; // returns "9" I know that 1,09 isn't a number. What does the comma do in the last piece of code? More Examples if (0,9) alert("ok"); // alert if (9,0) alert("ok"); // don't alert alert(1); alert(2); alert(3); // 3 …

Read More
How can I remove a specific item from an array?

I have an array of numbers and I'm using the .push() method to add elements to it. Is there a simple way to remove a specific element from an array? I'm looking for the equivalent of something like: array.remove(…

Read More