Why can't a class or an interface receive private or protected access modifiers?

java access-modifiers
ipkiss picture ipkiss · Jul 18, 2011 · Viewed 21.6k times · Source

I am reading some Java text and the text says that we can only apply public or default access modifier for class and interface. Therefore, it is a compiling error if we declare:

private class A {}

or

protected class A{}

I am just curious why a class or an interface cannot receive private or protected access modifiers?

Answer

Michael Myers picture Michael Myers · Jul 18, 2011

private means "only visible within the enclosing class".

protected means "only visible within the enclosing class and any subclasses, and also anywhere in the enclosing class's package".

private, therefore, has no meaning when applied to a top-level class; the same goes for the first part of the definition of protected. The second part of protected could apply, but it is covered by the default (package-protected) modifier, so protected is part meaningless and part redundant.

Both private and protected can be (and frequently are) applied to nested classes and interfaces, just never top-level classes and interfaces.

Related questions

What is the difference between public, protected, package-private and private in Java?

In Java, are there clear rules on when to use each of access modifiers, namely the default (package private), public, protected and private, while making class and interface and dealing with inheritance?

Read More
What is the default access modifier in Java?

What is the default access modifier for a method or an instance variable if I do not state it explicitly? For example: package flight.booking; public class FlightLog { private SpecificFlight flight; FlightLog(SpecificFlight flight) { this.flight = flight; } } Is the access …

Read More
Can non-static methods modify static variables

I am wondering how a non static method can modify a static variable. I know that static methods can only access other static methods and static variables. However, is the other side true? Can non-static methods access only non-static variables? …

Read More