Why is spawning threads in Java EE container discouraged?

java multithreading jakarta-ee
LiorH picture LiorH · Feb 10, 2009 · Viewed 52.5k times · Source

One of the first things I've learned about Java EE development is that I shouldn't spawn my own threads inside a Java EE container. But when I come to think about it, I don't know the reason.

Can you clearly explain why it is discouraged?

I am sure most enterprise applications need some kind of asynchronous jobs like mail daemons, idle sessions, cleanup jobs etc.

So, if indeed one shouldn't spawn threads, what is the correct way to do it when needed?

Answer

Robin picture Robin · Feb 10, 2009

It is discouraged because all resources within the environment are meant to be managed, and potentially monitored, by the server. Also, much of the context in which a thread is being used is typically attached to the thread of execution itself. If you simply start your own thread (which I believe some servers will not even allow), it cannot access other resources. What this means, is that you cannot get an InitialContext and do JNDI lookups to access other system resources such as JMS Connection Factories and Datasources.

There are ways to do this "correctly", but it is dependent on the platform being used.

The commonj WorkManager is common for WebSphere and WebLogic as well as others

More info here

And here

Also somewhat duplicates this one from this morning

UPDATE: Please note that this question and answer relate to the state of Java EE in 2009, things have improved since then!

Related questions

Illegal access: this web application instance has been stopped already

I have a class which has an init-method defined in xml <bean id="appStarter" class="com.myapp.myClass" init-method="init" destroy-method="destroy"/> myClass: public class myClass{ private Thread t; public void init() { t = new Thread() { @Override public void …

Read More
How are Threads allocated to handle Servlet request?

Can someone please explain what is thread per request and thread per connection? Which model do servlets work on? How threads are allocated to handle HTTP requests? Is it thread/request or connection? And let's say if I want to …

Read More
Java ThreadLocal static?

Setting a value in Thread Local: //Class A holds the static ThreadLocal variable. Class A{ public static ThreadLocal<X> myThreadLocal = new ThreadLocal<X>(); .... } //A Class B method sets value in A's static ThreadLocal variable class B{ { …

Read More