cobertura vs clover

java unit-testing cobertura clover
Marcin Michalski picture Marcin Michalski · Feb 2, 2011 · Viewed 8.3k times · Source

We are thinking about utilizing one of these tools in our development procedure. Our environment extensively uses mvn and eclipse.

Which one in your opinion is the best utility for checking test coverage? I realize that it may depend on the situation to determine when it is better to use cobertura over clover and vice-versa.

Thanks in advance

Answer

James Woods picture James Woods · Mar 10, 2011

I have also tried Clover, Cobertura and Emma. We are now using Cobertura. It took me about a day to integrate Cobertura into our headless build, it produces the statistics we require and the eCobertura eclipse plugin is primitive, but useable and informative. There is a very nice Hudson plugin for Cobertura also.

We where previously using Emma. Emma with the EclEmma plugin is about equivalent to Cobertura/eCobertura. Emma integration into Ant is a fracton more complex and doesn't offer a complexity factor. The EclEmma plugin is nicer and more mature then eCobertura. The Hudson plugin is equivalent and as easy to configure. Our reason for moving away from Emma was that the code base has not been maintained for some years now and we where having problems as it is rendered useless if encounters code using Lombok.

I spent a week (in parallel with other tasks) playing with Clover and coudln't get it working. I asked around my colleagues, some with a lot of experience, and only one had heard of somebody getting Clover working in the build, and that was difficult.

As Cobertura provides everything that we required, is easy to work with and is free we saw no reason to spend money on Clover.

Related questions

How do I test a private function or a class that has private methods, fields or inner classes?

How do I unit test (using xUnit) a class that has internal private methods, fields or nested classes? Or a function that is made private by having internal linkage (static in C/C++) or is in a private (anonymous) namespace? …

Read More
How to mock void methods with Mockito

How to mock methods with void return type? I implemented an observer pattern but I can't mock it with Mockito because I don't know how. And I tried to find an example on the Internet but didn't succeed. My class …

Read More
Mocking static methods with Mockito

I've written a factory to produce java.sql.Connection objects: public class MySQLDatabaseConnectionFactory implements DatabaseConnectionFactory { @Override public Connection getConnection() { try { return DriverManager.getConnection(...); } catch (SQLException e) { throw new RuntimeException(e); } } } I'd like to validate the parameters passed to DriverManager.getConnection, …

Read More