Atomikos vs JOTM vs Bitronix vs?

java transactions jakarta-ee jta
HDave picture HDave · Jun 5, 2010 · Viewed 23.3k times · Source

I am new to JTA and it's underlying transaction managers. Can anyone explain the pros/cons of each of these? Feel free to add others I didn't list in title.

Also, don't the major applications servers (WebSphere, JBoss, Glassfish) have their own JTA compliant transaction manager? In those environments, would you still use these third party implementations?

Answer

Pascal Thivent picture Pascal Thivent · Jun 5, 2010

I am new to JTA and it's underlying transaction managers. Can anyone explain the pros/cons of each of these? Feel free to add others I didn't list in title.

Standalone transaction managers I'm aware of include Bitronix, SimpleJTA, Tyrex (dead?), JOTM (used in Jonas), GeronimoTM/Jencks (used in Geronimo), JBossTS (used in JBoss) and Atomikos.

I've never tested them all extensively (and this is what you would have to do if you have to choose one) so I can't provide an exhaustive pros/cons (and that would require some work). But here are some links:

Just in case, here is my very personal point of view:

  • I've seen lots of complains about JOTM.
  • I think that GeronimoTM/Jencks lacks of documentation.
  • SimpleJTA doesn't implement JTS and is not active.
  • Bitronix is decently documentation but doesn't offer support.
  • Atomikos is an impressive product, well documented and does offer support.
  • JBossTS aka ArjunaTS is definitely a mature product (see the announcement of the acquisition for some history) and does offer support.

Personally, I'd shortlist Atomikos and JBossTS and test them hardcore if I had to choose one.

Also, don't the major applications servers (WebSphere, JBoss, Glassfish) have their own JTA compliant transaction manager?

Of course they do, JTA is part of the Java EE specification, a Java EE server has to support it.

In those environments, would you still use these third party implementations?

No, I'd use the provided transaction manager (for simplicity, support, etc).

Related questions

Difference between UserTransaction and EntityTransaction

Title says it all: What is the difference between a UserTransaction and an EntityTransaction? My rudimentary understanding is that UserTransaction is used when JTA is required (e.g. to do queries on mulitple things), and that EntityTransaction is used when …

Read More
How to manage transaction for database and file system in Java EE environment?

I store file’s attributes (size, update time…) in database. So the problem is how to manage transaction for database and file. In a Java EE environment, JTA is just able to manage database transaction. In case, updating database is …

Read More
EJB3 transaction rollback

I'm using CMT in EJB3 state-less session beans. Also I've created my own Exception having the annotation "@ApplicationException (rollback=true)". Do I have to use "context.setRollbackOnly()" when I want to rollback the transaction? Can I just rollback the transaction …

Read More