Difference between Inheritance and Composition

java oop inheritance composition
gmhk picture gmhk · Mar 8, 2010 · Viewed 224.7k times · Source

Are Composition and Inheritance the same? If I want to implement the composition pattern, how can I do that in Java?

Answer

polygenelubricants picture polygenelubricants · Mar 8, 2010

They are absolutely different. Inheritance is an "is-a" relationship. Composition is a "has-a".

You do composition by having an instance of another class C as a field of your class, instead of extending C. A good example where composition would've been a lot better than inheritance is java.util.Stack, which currently extends java.util.Vector. This is now considered a blunder. A stack "is-NOT-a" vector; you should not be allowed to insert and remove elements arbitrarily. It should've been composition instead.

Unfortunately it's too late to rectify this design mistake, since changing the inheritance hierarchy now would break compatibility with existing code. Had Stack used composition instead of inheritance, it can always be modified to use another data structure without violating the API.

I highly recommend Josh Bloch's book Effective Java 2nd Edition

  • Item 16: Favor composition over inheritance
  • Item 17: Design and document for inheritance or else prohibit it

Good object-oriented design is not about liberally extending existing classes. Your first instinct should be to compose instead.

See also:

Related questions

Why use inheritance at all?

I know the question has been discussed before, but it seems always under the assumption that inheritance is at least sometimes preferable to composition. I'd like to challenge that assumption in hopes of gaining some understanding. My question is this: …

Read More
Extends JFrame vs. creating it inside the program

When making an application using Swing, I've seen people do one of the two things to create a JFrame. Which is a better approach and why? I'm a beginner at Java and programming. My only source of learning is books, …

Read More
How should I have explained the difference between an Interface and an Abstract class?

In one of my interviews, I have been asked to explain the difference between an Interface and an Abstract class. Here's my response: Methods of a Java interface are implicitly abstract and cannot have implementations. A Java abstract class can …

Read More