What is the difference between google's ImmutableList and Collections.unmodifiableList ()?

java collections comparison guava
Roman picture Roman · Feb 2, 2010 · Viewed 26k times · Source

From ImmutableList javadocs:

Unlike Collections.unmodifiableList(java.util.List), which is a view of a separate collection that can still change, an instance of ImmutableList contains its own private data and will never change. ImmutableList is convenient for public static final lists ("constant lists") and also lets you easily make a "defensive copy" of a list provided to your class by a caller.

Does it mean that:

  1. if I have ImmutableList of Dimension objects (for example) then I can't change any Dimension object in it?
  2. and if I have Collections.unmodifiableList (list) of Dimension objects then I can't only add or delete any object but I can change them (for example call setDimension(width, height) method)?

Answer

Yishai picture Yishai · Feb 2, 2010

No, the immutability is only applied to the amount and references of the objects in the Collection, and does not address the mutability of objects you put in the Collection.

What Immutable list gains over the standard JDK Collections.unmodifiableList is that by using ImmutableList you are guaranteed that the objects referenced, their order and the size of the list cannot change from any source. With Collections.unmodifiableList if something else has a reference to the underlying list, that code can modify the list even though you have a reference to an unmodifiable list.

If, however, you want true immutability, you have to fill the list with immutable objects.

Related questions

Initialization of an ArrayList in one line

I wanted to create a list of options for testing purposes. At first, I did this: ArrayList<String> places = new ArrayList<String>(); places.add("Buenos Aires"); places.add("Córdoba"); places.add("La Plata"); Then, I …

Read More
How do I efficiently iterate over each entry in a Java Map?

If I have an object implementing the Map interface in Java and I wish to iterate over every pair contained within it, what is the most efficient way of going through the map? Will the ordering of elements depend on …

Read More
How to make a new List in Java

We create a Set as: Set myset = new HashSet() How do we create a List in Java?

Read More