What is the difference between "Class.forName()" and "Class.forName().newInstance()"?

Question

What is the difference between Class.forName() and Class.forName().newInstance()?

I do not understand the significant difference (I have read something about them!). Could you please help me?

Answer 1

Maybe an example demonstrating how both methods are used will help you to understand things better. So, consider the following class:

package test;

public class Demo {

    public Demo() {
        System.out.println("Hi!");
    }

    public static void main(String[] args) throws Exception {
        Class clazz = Class.forName("test.Demo");
        Demo demo = (Demo) clazz.newInstance();
    }
}

As explained in its javadoc, calling Class.forName(String) returns the Class object associated with the class or interface with the given string name i.e. it returns test.Demo.class which is affected to the clazz variable of type Class.

Then, calling clazz.newInstance() creates a new instance of the class represented by this Class object. The class is instantiated as if by a new expression with an empty argument list. In other words, this is here actually equivalent to a new Demo() and returns a new instance of Demo.

And running this Demo class thus prints the following output:

Hi!

The big difference with the traditional new is that newInstance allows to instantiate a class that you don't know until runtime, making your code more dynamic.

A typical example is the JDBC API which loads, at runtime, the exact driver required to perform the work. EJBs containers, Servlet containers are other good examples: they use dynamic runtime loading to load and create components they don't know anything before the runtime.

Actually, if you want to go further, have a look at Ted Neward paper Understanding Class.forName() that I was paraphrasing in the paragraph just above.

EDIT (answering a question from the OP posted as comment): The case of JDBC drivers is a bit special. As explained in the DriverManager chapter of Getting Started with the JDBC API:

(...) A Driver class is loaded, and therefore automatically registered with the DriverManager, in one of two ways:

1. by calling the method Class.forName. This explicitly loads the driver class. Since it does not depend on any external setup, this way of loading a driver is the recommended one for using the DriverManager framework. The following code loads the class acme.db.Driver:

   Class.forName("acme.db.Driver");
   

   If acme.db.Driver has been written so that loading it causes an instance to be created and also calls DriverManager.registerDriver with that instance as the parameter (as it should do), then it is in the DriverManager's list of drivers and available for creating a connection.

2. (...)

In both of these cases, it is the responsibility of the newly-loaded Driver class to register itself by calling DriverManager.registerDriver. As mentioned, this should be done automatically when the class is loaded.

To register themselves during initialization, JDBC driver typically use a static initialization block like this:

package acme.db;

public class Driver {

    static {
        java.sql.DriverManager.registerDriver(new Driver());
    }

    ...
}

Calling Class.forName("acme.db.Driver") causes the initialization of the acme.db.Driver class and thus the execution of the static initialization block. And Class.forName("acme.db.Driver") will indeed "create" an instance but this is just a consequence of how (good) JDBC Driver are implemented.

As a side note, I'd mention that all this is not required anymore with JDBC 4.0(added as a default package since Java 7) and the new auto-loading feature of JDBC 4.0 drivers. See JDBC 4.0 enhancements in Java SE 6.