Concurrent and Blocking Queue in Java
I have the classic problem of a thread pushing events to the incoming queue of a second thread. Only this time, I am very interested about performance. What I want to achieve is:
- I want concurrent access to the queue, the producer pushing, the receiver poping.
- When the queue is empty, I want the consumer to block to the queue, waiting for the producer.
My first idea was to use a LinkedBlockingQueue, but I soon realized that it is not concurrent and the performance suffered. On the other hand, I now use a ConcurrentLinkedQueue, but still I am paying the cost of wait() / notify() on each publication. Since the consumer, upon finding an empty queue, does not block, I have to synchronize and wait() on a lock. On the other part, the producer has to get that lock and notify() upon every single publication. The overall result is that I am paying the cost of
sycnhronized (lock) {lock.notify()} in every single publication, even when not needed.
What I guess is needed here, is a queue that is both blocking and concurrent. I imagine a push() operation to work as in ConcurrentLinkedQueue, with an extra notify() to the object when the pushed element is the first in the list. Such a check I consider to already exist in the ConcurrentLinkedQueue, as pushing requires connecting with the next element. Thus, this would be much faster than synchronizing every time on the external lock.
Is something like this available/reasonable?
Answer
I think you can stick to java.util.concurrent.LinkedBlockingQueue regardless of your doubts. It is concurrent. Though, I have no idea about its performance. Probably, other implementation of BlockingQueue will suit you better. There's not too many of them, so make performance tests and measure.