EJB 3.0 - Nested Transaction != Requires New?

jakarta-ee transactions ejb-3.0 nested-transactions
NorRen picture NorRen · May 30, 2012 · Viewed 17.4k times · Source

I just read the Transactions Chapter (10) of "Mastering EJB 3.0" and now I'm confused about nested transactions.

The book says

"The EJB-defined transaction manager does not support nested transactions; it requires support for only flat transactions." (Site 278, Note)

This fact is described not only by this book, I found this statement in other books / websites.

But if I call a "Requires New" annotated Method from a, let's say "Required" annotated Methode, what I have is a nested transaction, isn't it? I can roll back the inner transaction or commit it, without affecting the outer transaction. And if I want the outer Transaction to be aborted, I throw an EJBException back and the whole transaction will be rolled back.

So is it just that this behavior is not required by the EJB 3.0 specification or have i misunderstood something? I just can't get the difference between nested transactions and the described behavior.

Regards Norman

Answer

Brett Kail picture Brett Kail · May 30, 2012

RequiresNew does not create a nested transaction because the first transaction is suspended while the second transaction is running. A nested transaction looks like this:

Nested transaction example
> method1 - begin tran1
  > method2 - begin tran2
    workA
  < method2 - commit tran2
< method1 - rollback tran1 (tran2 also rolled back because it's nested)

Instead, RequiresNew looks like this:

EJB RequiresNew example
> method1 - begin tran1
  > method2 - suspend tran1, begin tran2
    workA
  < method2 - commit tran2, resume tran1
< method1 - rollback tran1 (tran2 remains committed)

Related questions

EJB3 transaction rollback

I'm using CMT in EJB3 state-less session beans. Also I've created my own Exception having the annotation "@ApplicationException (rollback=true)". Do I have to use "context.setRollbackOnly()" when I want to rollback the transaction? Can I just rollback the transaction …

Read More
EJB3 Transaction Propagation

I have a stateless bean something like: @Stateless public class MyStatelessBean implements MyStatelessLocal, MyStatelessRemote { @PersistenceContext(unitName="myPC") private EntityManager mgr; @TransationAttribute(TransactionAttributeType.SUPPORTED) public void processObjects(List<Object> objs) { // this method just processes the data; no need for …

Read More
EJB: Avoid Transaction rollback

When a (transactional) method of an EJB calls another (transactional) method of another EJB, and an exception is thrown in the second, but catched in the first one, it seems that the transaction is automatically rolled back when the second …

Read More