Comparing HTTP and FTP for transferring files

http ftp network-programming file-transfer
Mystic picture Mystic · Apr 4, 2009 · Viewed 120k times · Source

What are the advantages (or limitations) of one over the other for transferring files over the Internet?

(I am aware of secure forms of both protocols. I'd like to hear comparisons through personal experiences in terms of performance, reliability, file size limitations etc.)

Answer

John Ellinwood picture John Ellinwood · Apr 4, 2009

Here's a performance comparison of the two. HTTP is more responsive for request-response of small files, but FTP may be better for large files if tuned properly. FTP used to be generally considered faster. FTP requires a control channel and state be maintained besides the TCP state but HTTP does not. There are 6 packet transfers before data starts transferring in FTP but only 4 in HTTP.

I think a properly tuned TCP layer would have more effect on speed than the difference between application layer protocols. The Sun Blueprint Understanding Tuning TCP has details.

Heres another good comparison of individual characteristics of each protocol.

Related questions

What is the fastest way to transfer files over a network (FTP, HTTP, RSync, etc.)

I'm trying to figure out the best way to transfer large amounts of data over a network between two systems. I am currently looking into either FTP, HTTP, or RSync, and I am wondering which one is the fastest. I've …

Read More
What is the maximum file size I can transfer using HTTP? And using FTP?

Added: I am conducting a study for a new system we're going to develop in my work. It consists in authenticating users, displaying what files they want to download and downloading them. Also, if the files are not readily available, …

Read More
Choosing buffer size for FTP and HTTP transfers

How does one choose the size of a buffer (bytes I read from or write to socket) for the maximum throughput when implementing a low-level HTTP and FTP transfer? My application should transfer data with HTTP or FTP on connections …

Read More