Chunked encoding and content-length header

http encoding transfer chunked
p00ya00 picture p00ya00 · Jul 21, 2010 · Viewed 29.9k times · Source

Is it possible to set the content-length header and also use chunked transfer encoding? and does doing so solve the problem of not knowing the length of the response at the client side when using chunked?

the scenario I'm thinking about is when you have a large file to transfer and there's no problem in determining its size, but it's too large to be buffered completely. (If you're not using chunked, then the whole response must get buffered first? Right??)

thanks.

Answer

Julian Reschke picture Julian Reschke · Jul 21, 2010

1) No: "Messages MUST NOT include both a Content-Length header field and a non-identity transfer-coding. If the message does include a non-identity transfer-coding, the Content-Length MUST be ignored." (RFC 2616, Section 4.4)

2) And no, you can use Content-Length and stream; the protocol doesn't constrain how your implementation works.

Related questions

Java URL encoding of query string parameters

Say I have a URL http://example.com/query?q= and I have a query entered by the user such as: random word £500 bank $ I want the result to be a properly encoded URL: http://example.com/query?q=random%20…

Read More
Is a URL allowed to contain a space?

Is a URI (specifically an HTTP URL) allowed to contain one or more space characters? If a URL must be encoded, is + just a commonly followed convention, or a legitimate alternative? In particular, can someone point to an RFC that …

Read More
In Python, how do I decode GZIP encoding?

I downloaded a webpage in my python script. In most cases, this works fine. However, this one had a response header: GZIP encoding, and when I tried to print the source code of this web page, it had all symbols …

Read More